Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Crack Growth”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 109 records · Page 6

Stress Intensity Thresholds for Development of Reliable Brittle Materials

Brittle material failure in high consequence systems can appear random and unpredictable at subcritical stresses. Gaps in our understanding of how structural flaws and environmental factors (humidity, temperature) impact fracture propagation need to be addressed to circumvent this issue. A combined experimental and computational approach composed of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, numerical modeling, and atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been undertaken to identify mechanisms of slow crack growth in silicate glasses. AFM characterization of crack growth as slow as 10 -13 m/s was observed, with some stepwise crack growth. MD simulations have identified the critical role of inelastic relaxation in crack propagation, including evolution of the structure during relaxation. A numerical model for the existence of a stress intensity threshold, a stress intensity below which a fracture will not propagate, was developed. This transferrable model for predicting slow crack growth is being incorporated into mission-based programs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Complex Dependence of Calcite Crack Kinetics on Salinity: The Role of DLVO and Hydration Forces

Abstract Subcritical crack growth (SCG) plays an important role in many geological processes such as delayed earth rupture and rock weathering. The complex dependency of SCG on the in‐crack fluid chemistry, however, is still poorly understood. In this study, we utilize the newly developed surface force‐based fracture theory (SFFT) to elucidate the relative contributions of surface forces and solute transport to the crack growth kinetics of calcite in NaCl solutions. Expanding on Barenblatt's cohesive crack model, SFFT introduces an effective stress intensity at the crack tip that encompasses all the relevant intermolecular forces across the crack in addition to the external far‐field stresses. The nonlinear system of equations portraying the crack opening profile, the solute distribution in a propagating crack, and the crack growth velocity are numerically solved via an implicit scheme. After carefully calibrating the model for calcite‐water systems, the SFFT is used to predict the SCG response of calcite at different NaCl concentrations, based on various hypotheses. These predictions are then compared to existing SCG data from the literature. We demonstrate that the experimentally observed variation of SCG rate with NaCl concentration cannot be explained solely by DLVO forces (electrostatic and Van der Waals interactions). This can be remediated by introducing an exponentially decaying hydration force with a nonlinear, nonmonotonic dependence on NaCl concentration. Furthermore, we demonstrate that accounting for both diffusive and advective transport of ions is important in explaining the absence of a stage‐II SCG response for calcite in electrolyte solutions. Plain Language Summary Subcritical crack growth (SCG) refers to the slow propagation of cracks in materials under a stress below the threshold for catastrophic failure. SCG is a key process in many geological events, for example, delayed earth ruptures and rock weathering. New initiatives such as underground CO 2 and H 2 storage in carbonate reservoirs further call for better understanding of SCG in carbonate minerals subjected to varying fluid chemistry. This study examines the SCG of calcite, a key mineral found in carbonate rocks, intergranular cement in sandstones, and filling material in mineral veins and faults, determining their deformation and strength. A mathematical model is developed to describe how the crack opens and propagates, how solutes (like salts) distribute within the crack, and how the crack surfaces interact with each other. We used the model to predict calcite SCG in water at different salt concentrations and compared it with experimental data. Our results revealed that the hydration force is the dominating factor in determining the complex, non‐linear dependency of SCG on salinity. We also found that both the movement of ions by diffusion and by bulk water flow are crucial for explaining the SCG rates, especially when the cracks grow quickly. Key Points Surface Force‐Based Fracture Theory predicts the complex subcritical crack growth patterns of calcite crystals immersed in NaCl solutions Results highlight the dominant role of hydration forces in altering the fracture behavior of calcite compared to VdW and electric double‐layer forces Advective solute transport explains the absence of stages‐II and ‐III subcritical crack growth responses in solid‐liquid systems

DLVO↗

Cracking Behavior of Irradiated Ex-Plant Materials

The cracking behavior of reactor core internal materials is a key factor for the long-term safety and availability of light water reactors. Subject to high-temperature coolant, thermal and mechanical loading, and neutron irradiation, reactor core internal materials are susceptible to several degradation mechanisms during power operation. To understand the long-term effects of neutron irradiation, irradiated materials harvested from a decommissioned reactor were studied for their cracking susceptibility and fracture resistance. Small compact-tension specimens were machined from different locations on the baffle plates with irradiation doses ranging from 0.06 to 48.5 dpa. Crack growth rate and fracture toughness J-resistance (J-R) curve tests were performed on these specimens in a simulated light water reactor environment, and the fracture morphologies of the tested samples were examined with a scanning electron microscope. All samples behaved similarly under cyclic loading, and no deteriorated corrosion-fatigue behavior was observed in the test environments. Under constant load, no elevated cracking susceptibility was observed either in these samples at low stress intensity factors. However, a rapid cracking behavior featuring very high crack growth rates was observed in several high-dose samples. This rapid crack growth behavior was activated when the applied stress intensity factor, K, was sufficiently high. Once activated, the rapid crack growth remained steady even when the K was lowered to the pre-activation level and stopped only when the K was reduced drastically. Yet, the rapid crack growth could be re-activated repeatedly in these samples by raising the K above the initial activation level. This rapid cracking response may be related to the severe irradiation embrittlement experienced by these samples. The J-R curve tests performed with these samples showed a significant decline in fracture toughness with increasing neutron irradiation. Local cracking at the crack tip facilitated by the severe irradiation embrittlement of this material may be responsible for the rapid crack growth behavior demonstrated by this decommissioned material.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

On formulations for modeling pressurized cracks within phase-field methods for fracture

Over the past few decades, the phase-field method for fracture has seen widespread appeal due to the many benefits associated with its ability to regularize a sharp crack geometry. Along the way, several different models for including the effects of pressure loads on the crack faces have been developed. Further, this work investigates the performance of these models and compares them to a relatively new formulation for incorporating crack-face pressure loads. It is shown how the new formulation can be obtained either by modifying the trial space in the traditional variational principle or by postulating a new functional that is dependent on the rates of the primary variables. The key differences between the new formulation and existing models for pressurized cracks in a phase-field setting are highlighted. Model-based simulations developed with discretized versions of the new formulation and existing models are then used to illustrate the advantages and differences. In order to analyze the results, a domain form of the J-integral is developed for diffuse cracks subjected to pressure loads. Results are presented for a one-dimensional cohesive crack, steady crack growth, and crack nucleation from a pressurized enclosure.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Time-dependent THMC properties and microstructural evolution of damaged rocks in excavation damage zone

Modeling coupled thermo-hydro-mechanical-chemical (THMC) processes in host rocks near high-level nuclear waste (HLW) repositories at various time scales is an extremely challenging task. The current study integrates experimental, theoretical, and numerical methods in assessing the evolution of excavation damage zone (EDZ) over time and its implication on the long-term migration of hazardous species. Argillite and rock salt and are the focus of this study. The first part of the report presents a novel time-dependent directional microcrack damage theory for generic brittle rocks. It features detailed statistical description of the microcracks within a damaged solid, permitting a direct upscaling of microscale processes such as crack growth kinetics, crack closure/opening, sliding friction to explain the macroscopic creep, nonlinear elasticity, shear dilation, and loading-unloading hysteresis. This provides a basic platform for describing the anisotropic mechanical and transport properties of damaged rocks during excavation and subsequent THMC loadings. The model is validated and numerically implemented to Finite Element (FE) package ABAQUS through the user-defined material (UMAT) interface and have demonstrated great potential in resolving the time-dependent and anisotropic evolution of damage in the EDZ. The second part of the report presents a multi-scale experimental effort in characterizing the thermal, hydraulic, and mechanical properties of Mancos shale and Avery Island salt. For the Mancos shale, triaxial compression tests are performed at different confining pressures and temperatures to probe its thermomechanical properties relevant to HLW repositories. The obtained stress-strain data are interpreted using the proposed directional damage theory. Post-test specimens are subjected to gas permeability tests to reveal the correlation between permeability and the degree of microcracking. At microscale, temperature-controlled nanoindentation tests are performed and found a linear correlation between fracture toughness and elastic modulus from 25°C to 300°C. For Avery Island salt, we have designed and manufactured a novel relative-humidity controlled uniaxial creep device. Long-term creep tests at low stresses (< 5 MPa) are performed at different levels of relative humidity (RH). Besides confirming the much higher creep rates as one would expect through extrapolating the high-stress creep data, the results reveal that the steady-state creep rate of rock salt is strongly dependent on the ambient RH, an aspect that is often neglected in the literature. Both behaviors can be attributed to the pressure-solution creep mechanism which dominates at low stress and high RH levels. The third part of the report explores a set of numerical strategies in modeling the THMC behavior of porous geomaterials. A fully implicit, monolithic FE solution that can flexibly interface with different material models and coupling mechanisms for THMC problems is developed and verified through the ABAQUS user-defined element (UEL) interface. The scheme is used to study the THM response of a hypothetical HLW storage site with reference to an existing in-situ heater test. Strategies for integrating the UEL and the microcrack UMAT are suggested. Another numerical endeavor of this study is to implement a higher-order asymptotic homogenization method to account for the heterogeneous porous structures. The same method is then extended to perform microstructure-informed thermo-mechanical modeling of generalized continua. The above outcomes of this project provide a strong thrust towards enhancing the fundamental understanding and modeling capability of the long-term evolution of host rocks in EDZ, thus helping achieve the design goal of 1-million-year isolation of high-level nuclear wastes.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Predicting microstructurally sensitive fatigue‐crack path in WE43 magnesium using high‐fidelity numerical modeling and three‐dimensional experimental characterization

Abstract Microstructurally small fatigue‐crack growth in polycrystalline materials is highly three‐dimensional due to sensitivity to local microstructural features (e.g., grains). One requirement for modeling microstructurally sensitive crack propagation is establishing the criteria that govern crack evolution, including crack deflection. Here, a high‐fidelity finite‐element modeling framework is used to assess the performance and validity of various crack‐growth criteria, including slip‐based metrics (e.g., fatigue‐indicator parameters), as potential criteria for predicting three‐dimensional crack paths in polycrystalline materials. The modeling framework represents cracks as geometrically explicit discontinuities and involves voxel‐based remeshing, mesh‐gradation control, and a crystal‐plasticity constitutive model. The predictions are compared to experimental measurements of WE43 magnesium samples subject to fatigue loading, for which three‐dimensional grain structures and fatigue‐crack surfaces were measured post‐mortem using near‐field high‐energy x‐ray diffraction microscopy and x‐ray computed tomography. Findings from this work are expected to improve the predictive capabilities of simulations involving microstructurally small fatigue‐crack growth in polycrystalline materials.

Engineering↗

On plasticity-enhanced interfacial toughness in bonded joints

Here, the performance and reliability of many structures and components depend on the integrity of interfaces between dissimilar materials. Interfacial toughness Γ is the key material parameter that characterizes resistance to interfacial crack growth, and Γ is known to depend on many factors including temperature. For example, previous work showed that the toughness of an epoxy/aluminum interface decreased 40 % as the test temperature was increased from -60 °C to room temperature (RT). Interfacial integrity at elevated temperatures is of considerable practical importance. Recent measurements show that instead of continuing to decrease with increasing temperature, Γ increases when test temperature is above RT. Cohesive zone finite element calculations of an adhesively bonded, asymmetric double cantilever beam specimen of the type used to measure Γ suggest that this increase in toughness may be a result of R-curve behavior generated by plasticity-enhanced toughening during stable subcritical crack growth with interfacial toughness defined as the critical steady-state limit value. In these calculations, which used an elastic-perfectly plastic epoxy model with a temperature-dependent yield strength, the plasticity-enhanced increase in Γ above its intrinsic value Γ o depended on the ratio of interfacial strength σ* to the yield strength σyb of the bond material. There is a nonlinear relationship between Γ/Γ o and σ*/σ yb with the value Γ/Γ o increasing rapidly above a threshold value of σ*/σ yb . The predicted increase in toughness can be significant. For example, there is nearly a factor of two predicted increase in Γ/Γ o during micrometer-scale crack-growth when σ*/σ yb = 2 (a reasonable choice for σ*/σ yb ). Furthermore, contrary to other reported results, plasticity-enhanced toughening can occur prior to crack advance as the cohesive zone forms and the peak stress at the tip of the original crack tip translates to the tip of the fully formed cohesive zone. These results suggest that plasticity-enhanced toughening should be considered when modeling interfaces at elevated temperatures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Structural integrity of additively manufactured stainless steel with cold sprayed barrier coating under combined cyclic loading

Integration of metal additive manufacturing (AM) and cold spray (CS) technologies provide an unprecedented opportunity to manufacture coated material systems with complex geometrical features. The application of these material systems in functionally critical components requires adequate structural integrity, particularly in the presence of cyclic loading. This article researches the multiaxial fatigue (axial-torsional cyclic loading) behavior of a coated material system consisting of 15Cr-5Ni precipitation-hardening stainless steel (15-5 PH SS) substrate additively manufactured by direct metal laser sintering with a layer of chromium carbide nickel (CrC-Ni) barrier coating deposited by CS. The influence of AM and CS-induced residual stresses on fatigue performance of test specimens was thoroughly studied. Additionally, the effect of surface roughness and processes induced defects were considered to explain the crack growth mechanism. Stresses assessed by synchrotron X-ray diffraction indicated a substantial accumulation of residual stresses, particularly in the outer surface of the as-fabricated 155 PH SS specimens. The state of residual stress was changed notably following the deposition of CrC-Ni coating in the axial, hoop, and radial directions of the fatigue test specimen. Also, CS deposition of CrC-Ni coating caused significant improvement in the surface quality of the additively manufactured components. Fatigue test results indicated, CS deposition of CrC-Ni substantially enhances the fatigue life of the AM-produced 15-5 PH SS substrate in all loading conditions, particularly in the high cycle fatigue regime. The improvement in the fatigue life of the specimens with coating was associated with a reduction in equivalent residual stress at the substrate surface and improvement in the specimens' surface condition (i.e., reduced surface roughness). The fractographic analysis of the specimen indicated the cracks tend to initiate in the surface of both as-fabricated and cold-sprayed specimens. However, the mechanism of crack growth changed notably following the deposition of CrC-Ni coating. The cracks tended to propagate in the planes parallel or with a small deviation from the build layers of the AM-produced specimens. On the other hand, deposition of CrC-Ni coating increased the deviation of crack growth plane from the build layers of the substrate.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Attaining regularization length insensitivity in phase-field models of ductile failure

In this work, a cohesive phase-field model of ductile fracture in a finite-deformation setting is presented. The model is based on a free-energy function in which both elastic and plastic work contributions are coupled to damage. Using a strictly variational framework, the field evolution equations, damage kinetics, and flow rule are jointly derived from a scalar least-action principle. Particular emphasis is placed on the use of a rational function for the stress degradation that maintains a fixed effective strength with decreasing regularization length. The model is employed to examine crack growth in pure mode-I problems through the generation of crack growth resistance (J-R) curves. In contrast to alternative models, the current formulation gives rise to J-R curves that are insensitive to the regularization length. Numerical evidence suggests convergence of local fields with respect to diminishing regularization length as well.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Impact of position and density of nanoscale voids on fracture initiation in iron from phase field fracture simulation

Understanding the impact of these bubbles on crack propagation, like that of helium bubble-induced cracking in irradiated materials is incredibly complex. A useful first study towards understanding bubble effects on fracture is to examine how voids impact fracture first. In this work, we used phase-field fracture simulations to examine the influence of voids and their distribution on Mode I fracture in Fe. Assuming brittle fracture, two simulation configurations were considered: (1) nanoscale systems with one or two voids, and (2) nanoscale systems with an experimentally relevant distribution of voids, with up to 20% void area. Results from simulations with one and two voids showed that voids within 10 nm of a crack tip reduce the stress required for crack growth, with the magnitude of reduction depending on void-to-crack orientation. Comparisons with linear elastic fracture mechanics and evaluation of one versus two void systems revealed deviations from linear superposition, implying complex interactions between void and crack tip stress fields. In multi-void simulations, as void sizes increase, the nearest void to the crack tip exerts a greater influence on fracture stress than the overall porosity. Furthermore this study provides valuable insights into the relationship between void size and concentration, and the stress necessary for crack growth, marking a step forward towards understanding He bubble-induced fracture in ferrous materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

In-situ, nanoscale fracture toughness measurements for improved mechanical interfaces

In this project, we demonstrated stable nanoscale fracture in single-crystal silicon using an in-situ wedge-loaded double cantilever beam (DCB) specimen. The fracture toughness KIC was calculated directly from instrumented measurement of force and displacement via finite element analysis with frictional corrections. Measurements on multiple test specimens were used to show K IC = 0.72 ± 0.07 MPa m 1/2 on {111} planes and observe the crack-growth resistance curve in <500 nm increments. The exquisite stability of crack growth, instrumented measurement of material response, and direct visual access to observe nanoscale fracture processes in an ideally brittle material differentiate this approach from prior DCB methods.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Toughening of interface networks through the introduction of weak links

The resistance of polycrystalline materials to intergranular fracture depends on the toughness of the interfaces between neighboring grains. Using finite element simulations on model, two-dimensional microstructures, we demonstrate that the steady-state crack growth resistance of a polycrystal that contains exclusively high toughness interfaces is suboptimal: its crack growth resistance may be increased by introducing a minority fraction of weak interfaces at random locations within the interface network. Furthermore, the weaker are these interfaces, the greater is their toughening effect. These weak interfaces toughen the material through crack deflection and branching, nucleation of secondary cracks, and inelastic dissipation within intact interfaces. Furthermore, our findings suggest that fracture resistance-oriented material development should not aim to eliminate all weak interfaces, but rather judiciously incorporate a low fraction of them.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Insights into Stress Corrosion Cracking and Dissolution of Metal Oxides

Oxide phases such as α-Fe2O3 (hematite) and α-Al2O3 (corundum) are highly insoluble in water; however, subcritical crack growth has been observed in humidity nonetheless. Chemically induced bond breaking at the crack tip appears unlikely due to sterically hindered molecular transport. The molecular mechanics of a crack in corundum with a reactive force field reveal minimal lattice trapping, leading to bond breaking before sufficient space opens for water transport. To address this, we model a pre-built blunt crack with space for H2O molecule adsorption at the tip and show that it reduces fracture toughness by lowering the critical J-integral. Then, we explore stress-enhanced dissolution to understand the mechanism of crack tip blunting in the oxide/water system. Density functional theory combined with metadynamics was employed to describe atomic dissolution from flat hematite and corundum surfaces in pure water. Strain accelerates dissolution, stabilizing intermediate states with broken bonds before full atom detachment, while the free energy profile of unstrained surfaces is almost monotonic. The atomistic calculations provided input for a kinetic model, predicting the shape evolution of a blunt crack tip, which displays three distinct regimes: (i) dissolution primarily away from the tip, (ii) enhanced blunting near but not at the apex, and (iii) sharpening near the apex. The transition between regimes occurs at a low strain, highlighting the critical role of water in the subcritical crack growth of oxide scales, with dissolution as the fundamental microscopic mechanism behind this process.

Chemistry↗

The role of surface forces in environment-enhanced cracking of brittle solids

Fracture initiation and propagation in brittle materials is promoted in surface-reactive (sorptive) environments, a phenomenon known as subcritical crack growth (SCG). Laboratory measured crack-propagation velocity vs. stress intensity factor relationships typically exhibit highly nonlinear, multi-stage characteristics that are sensitive to environmental factors such as adsorbate concentration and temperature. For practical purposes, empirical relationships (e.g., a power law) have been used to describe this complex phenomenon. However, how the overall SCG behavior emerges from the underlying fundamental processes near the crack tip, such as the interaction of the crack surfaces separated by only a few nanometers and mass transport within the nano-confined space, is still not well understood. This paper develops a mechanistic, surface-force-based fracture theory (SFFT) which integrates surface force models, fluid transport models, and linear elastic fracture mechanics to quantitatively explain the multi-stage characteristics of SCG in brittle solids. A numerical model is developed based on SFFT and solved through an implicit partitioned scheme for efficiency and modularity. The results are validated by Wiederhorn's data on crack propagation in soda-lime glasses at a wide range of relative humidity levels. We show that, for the first time, the entire range of an SCG curve can be captured by a single physics-based model. The predicted SCG curves reveal that the development of repulsive disjoining pressure behind the crack tip can be responsible for the reduced apparent fracture toughness in a sorptive environment. In conclusion, the shape of the SCG curve, and its changes with respect to the environment, is found to critically depend on the assumed transport models.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fracture resistance of hierarchical Cu–Mo nanocomposite thin films

We report the fracture behavior of high-temperature co-sputtered Cu/Mo nanocomposite thin films was investigated through in situ 3-point bend testing of pre-notched microbeams in SEM. The as-synthesized nanocomposites present hierarchical nano/microstructures composed of a matrix of phase-separated Cu–Mo with nanoscale ligaments dispersed with sub-micron scale Cu-rich islands containing Mo nano-precipitates. Results show a significant crack growth resistance in the hierarchical nanocomposite, several times higher than that measured in Cu/Mo nanoscale multilayers. Based on electron microscopy characterization, three mechanisms of crack growth resistance in the hierarchical structures are proposed: crack bridging by the Cu-rich layer, crack deflection via shear along the Cu/Mo interface, and multiple cracking. This work demonstrates an approach to increase toughness in high strength nanocomposites through interface micro-structure design.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fatigue performance of laser powder bed fusion hydride-dehydride Ti-6Al-4V powder

We report hydride-dehydride (HDH) Ti-6Al-4V alloy with particle size distribution of 50–120 µm is laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) processed using optimum processing parameters and a near-fully dense structure with a density of 99.9 % is achieved. Microstructural observations and phase analyses indicate formation of columnar β grains with acicular α/α' phases in as-built condition. The roughness of the as-fabricated samples is significant with an average roughness of R a = 15.71 ± 3.96 µm and a root mean square roughness of R rms = 108.4 ± 24.9 µm, however, both values are reduced to R a = 0.19 ± 0.04 µm and R rms = 4.9 ± 0.6 µm after mechanical grinding. Mechanical tests are carried out on as-fabricated specimens followed by stress relief treatment. All samples are tested to failure in fatigue, under fully-reversed tension-compression conditions of R = –1. The as-built samples failed from the surface with crack initiation mainly at micro-notches, whereas after mechanically grinding, crack initiation changed to subsurface defects such as pores. Minimizing surface roughness by mechanically grinding eliminates surface micro-notches which improves fatigue strength in the high cycle fatigue region. Fatigue notch factor calculations showed that the effect of surface roughness was significantly lower when HDH powder is used compared to standard spherical powder. X-ray diffraction analysis revealed an in-plane compressive stress, micro-strain and grain refinement on the surface of the mechanically ground samples. Fractography observations (macroscale) revealed a fully brittle fracture in the first stage of crack growth with a transition to a dominantly ductile fracture in the third stage of crack growth. On the other hand, at the micro scale, even the brittle fracture regions showed evidence of ductile fracture within the α' martensite laths.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Temporal and Spatial Evolution of Non-Elastic Strain Accumulation in Stanstead Granite During Brittle Creep

Understanding the long-term behavior of brittle rocks requires fundamental consideration of time-dependent strain evolution and brittle creep processes. Previous studies have evaluated sub-critical crack growth during time-dependent deformation and damage evolution in brittle rocks; however, there is an incomplete knowledge of how damage evolves spatially and temporally within the body of intact rocks, where distributed regions of damage interact and coalesce during creep. This paper presents laboratory research focusing on evaluating brittle creep damage processes in Stanstead granite (SG) using 2-dimensional digital image correlation (2D-DIC). In the laboratory, the prismatic SG specimens were loaded beyond an estimated Crack Damage stress threshold (CD) level and then maintained a constant stress to initiate the creep process. DIC was used to characterize full-field spatiotemporal strain evolution, which was then interpreted in the context of local regions of “damage”, determined according to a strain-based criterion. Here, a method was proposed for identifying “existing” and “new” damage regions over specified intervals during the test, followed by spatial clustering of these regions to assess their spatiotemporal evolution. The clustering analysis results demonstrated the extension of existing damage regions was the main damage process during brittle creep, which is consistent with existing models of sub-critical crack growth. In addition, temporal analysis of tensile and shear strains on a point-by-point basis revealed both new damage formation and the strain concentration within existing damaged regions significantly contribute to overall specimen strain during primary creep. In contrast, during secondary creep, increases in specimen deformation are influenced by the accumulation of strains within already damaged regions.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗