Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Amorphous materials”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 127 records · Page 7
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Encapsulation of Monolayer 2D Materials Using Kinetic Energy-Controlled Pulsed Laser Deposition

The integration of monolayer (ML) two-dimensional (2D) materials into next-generation microelectronics, optoelectronics, and sensors is hindered by their sensitivity to environmental exposure. Deposition of additional layers for encapsulation or growth on ML 2D materials by versatile but energetic plasma techniques such as pulsed laser deposition (PLD) has not been considered at the monolayer level because of potential damage caused by hyperthermal species with kinetic energies (KEs) exceeding the threshold displacement energy (TDE) of the ML. Here, we describe a general strategy to understand and mitigate damage during PLD by reducing the incident KE of ablated species below the TDE of the 2D monolayer using background gas collisions. Ion flux diagnostics, combined with in situ Raman spectroscopy of monolayer graphene during PLD of amorphous boron nitride (a-BN) as a dielectric encapsulation layer, show that damage is primarily correlated with fast ions that penetrate the background gas in accordance with Beer’s Law and are often overlooked in ICCD imaging due to the dominance of the bright, delayed plasma luminescence. Significantly, if fast ions are eliminated and a ∼2 nm-thick a-BN layer is “soft landed”, the monolayer graphene is effectively protected from damage by high KE species in the boron nitride plasma plume. Deposited a-BN films display a characteristic dielectric constant of 3.6 at 100 kHz and tunable charge injection properties. Our results enable PLD as a viable option for encapsulation and thin film growth onto ML 2D materials, with implications for both fundamental research and device integration.

2D materials↗
DOE OSTI2025

Advancing Multiscale Simulation of Plasma-Surface Interfaces

We report the development of an atomistic-informed, surface-state-dependent predictive model for particle exchange in a carbon-tungsten plasma-surface interface. The predictive model uses machine learning (ML) techniques to learn the energy and angular distributions for particle exchange and rate functions for surface state evolution from molecular dynamics simulations of cumulative bombardment of tungsten by energetic carbon ions. Each predictive component is sensitive to the energy and trajectory of incident plasma species and the surface state. The surface state is represented by a set of surface state descriptors, which were derived from the atomistic surface state for each independent carbon bombardment event. These descriptors are representative of the composition and degree of amorphization of the outermost angstrom of surface material and were chosen to optimize predictive performance for particle exchange at the interface. The distributions for particle exchange (reflection/sputtering) are demonstrated to vary with each surface state descriptor, motivating the development of surface-state-dependent particle exchange models for plasma simulations. The performance of various ML methods was compared, including polynomial quantile regression, artificial neural networks, k-nearest neighbors, and random forest algorithms, with polynomial regression performing the best for interpolation and extrapolation of learned relationships. In addition to the particle exchange model, a neutral network was developed and used to identify data sufficiency throughout surface descriptor space, which will enable real-time feedback during future data production to ensure data is produced where it is most needed, and we provide commentary on improvements to the data production workflow for future endeavors.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Chemical Analysis of Tantalum Thin Films compared to Niobium Thin Films using SIMS and XPS

Superconducting qubits are a leading platform for quantum computation. These circuits are typically made from superconducting materials like aluminum or niobium. However, the amorphous niobium oxide and aluminum oxide on the surface of these circuits introduce considerable RF loss due to the presence of two-level systems (TLS), which limits the maximum coherence times T1 to ~100 μs. Capping the niobium qubits with a tantalum layer leads to a 3- 5x improvement [Bal et al., 2024]. But even in this case, tantalum forms an amorphous surface oxide that introduces loss. In an effort to devise strategies to eliminate the presence of this oxide, we present a comprehensive study on the nature of Ta oxide using x-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS) and secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) as a function of heat treatment. The thin films were annealed in ultra-high vacuum conditions and analyzed in situ to characterize the composition and evolution of the native tantalum oxide layer and oxide-metal interface. Our analysis reveals two critical differences between tantalum and niobium oxides: Nb2O5 completely dissolves at 400°C, while Ta2O5 persists even at 800°C. Additionally, tantalum oxide contains only a single suboxide (TaO), in contrast to niobium's two suboxides (NbO and NbO2). The suboxide of tantalum contributes minimally to the total oxide content and shows a relative increase with temperature. Understanding the oxide’s behavior will open new pathways for optimizing coherence times in tantalum qubits.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Chemically Recyclable Analogs of Styrene–Butadiene Copolymers Enabling Perfectly Linear Ethylene–Styrene Materials with Random Phenyl Distribution

Copolymerization of cyclopentene (CP) and 4-phenylcyclopentene (4PCP) at a full range of comonomer feed ratios is reported using Ru-based ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) yielding homogeneous copolymers analogous to poly(styrene-ran-1,4-butadiene) and poly(ethylene-ran-styrene) copolymers following hydrogenation under mild conditions. In all cases, total monomer conversions of 86%–92% yielded copolymers with compositions within 4% of monomer feeds. Analysis of equilibrium copolymerization thermodynamics, rarely performed on two cycloolefin monomers with low ring strain energies, provides rational design strategies for negotiating two monomers with different equilibrium monomer concentrations. Inverse-gated decoupled 13 C NMR analysis of dyad sequences on the resulting copolymer microstructures concludes a near-random distribution of comonomer units. The copolymers produced from ROMP have number-average molar masses up to 60 kg mol –1 , moderate dispersities (1.5 ± 0.1), and high trans olefin content (86% ± 2%) while glass-transitions temperatures follow the Fox equation and span the full range between homopolymer extremities of PCP (−96 °C) and P4PCP (17 °C). Unlike most prevulcanized elastomers, these materials undergo facile chemical recycling to monomer, producing complete ring-closing metathesis depolymerization (RCMD) of the polymer back to the CP comonomers. Quantitative olefin hydrogenation produced perfectly linear polyethylene with 4%–16% of the backbone carbons containing a phenyl pendant, analogous to ES copolymers with up to 71.5% w/w styrene units but with random distribution of the aromatic pendants. Thermal properties of these materials are discussed, which span from semicrystalline to amorphous, and with T g values notably less than the reported ES copolymer analogs at similar compositions.

animal feed↗
DOE OSTI2026

Low-Temperature Pyrolysis of Aliphatic Polymers Using a Fluorinated Amorphous Silica–Alumina: Cooperative Reactivity between a Redox-Active Radical and an Aluminum Lewis Site

Fluorinated amorphous silica–alumina (F-ASA) prepared by the thermolysis of Krossing’s Al(OC(CF 3 ) 3 ) 3 (PhF) Lewis superacid supported on silica is a very reactive catalyst that promotes the pyrolysis (cracking) of aliphatic polymer melts to produce low molecular weight hyperbranched oils. Initial spectroscopic studies reported previously (Gao, J.; Perras, F. A.; Conley, M. P. J. Am. Chem. Soc . 2025 , 147, 18145–18154) showed that this material contains a distribution of four-, five-, and six-coordinate aluminum sites and a small amount of Brønsted acid sites, similar to typical amorphous silica–alumina materials that are far less reactive in the pyrolysis of aliphatic polymer melts. The objective of this study was to determine whether other active sites present in F-ASA could facilitate pyrolysis reactions. This study provides evidence for the presence of a redox-active silicon oxycarbide persistent radical ((≡Si) 3 C•) in F-ASA. Mims ENDOR EPR experiments show that (≡Si) 3 C• is located close to aluminum. Contacting F-ASA with thianthrene (Th) results in oxidation to form the [Th •+ ][F–ASA] ion-pair, while reactions with 1-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (TEMPOH) result in H atom transfer to form TEMPO radical and F-ASA-H containing a mildly acidic (≡Si) 3 C–H. Poisoning studies show that both Lewis acidity and (≡Si) 3 C• are required for polymer pyrolysis reactivity. Finally, we propose that F-ASA promotes the formation of alkyl radicals in polymer melts, which are key intermediates in the thermal pyrolysis reactions of aliphatic polymers, involving the cooperative reactivity of both the Lewis acid and (≡Si) 3 C•.

aluminum↗
DOE OSTI2025

Plasma Flow Reactor Investigation into Nucleation of Uranium Oxide on Silica Substrates to Better Understand Fallout Formation

Understanding particulate formation in nuclear debris is critical for predicting fallout transport after a nuclear event. Improved characterization of fallout formation and transport could lead to better guidance for emergency response in a post-detonation scenario. By analyzing how U-oxides nucleate onto different forms of SiO 2 (crystalline and amorphous), we can gain insight into how entrained environmental materials may incorporate into fallout. In this experiment a Plasma Flow Reactor (PFR), was used to replicate the high temperature and extreme flow conditions in a nuclear fireball. Uranyl nitrate was injected into the plasma, and PFR-generated Uranium oxides were allowed to condense onto amorphous (nanoparticles of varying sizes) or crystalline (quartz) SiO 2 substrates. SiO 2 substrates were characterized before and after U-oxide deposition using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) based techniques (i.e. EDS) in order to characterize how U-oxides may nucleate onto these substrates. After a collection time of 4 minutes at an RF coil distance of 25cm, both the amorphous SiO 2 nanoparticles and the crystalline structures demonstrated dendritic nucleation of U-oxide species as identified by SEM/EDS.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Spectral Performance of Multilayer Amorphous Selenium and Selenium–Tellurium Photodetectors

The ability to robustly and with scalability detect single photons in the visible spectrum with wavelength resolution would transform many imaging applications. Theoretical studies propose an array of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) functionalized with semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) as a physical realization of such photon sensors. In this work, we report approaches to synthesize these CNT-QD nanostructures using DNA as a smart glue to connect CNTs to QDs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Microstructure and mechanical behavior of laser remelted amorphous Al-Ni-La welds

To explore the feasibility of using laser powder bed fusion systems to print bulk amorphous Al alloys, a single autogenous weld produced by laser remelting on a cast Al-5La-9Ni (at.%) alloy was studied for its microstructure and mechanical behavior. The solidification rates experienced by material within the welds were high enough to produce entirely amorphous regions within the welds. Welds were characterized using SEM, STEM, and APT and were found to contain Ni-rich amorphous clusters. Micropillar compression tests were used to assess mechanical properties of the welds and found that all of the amorphous regions exhibited yield strengths around 1 GPa. In conclusion, these results are discussed in the context of diffusivity of Ni and rare earth elements in liquid, glass forming ability, thermodynamic driving force for phase formation during solidification, free volume concentrations in bulk metallic glasses, and cluster-related softening.

APT↗
DOE OSTI2025

Elucidating the reversible exsolution–dissolution behaviour of high-entropy oxides in crystalline and amorphous phases

High-entropy oxides (HEOs), as a subclass of high-entropy materials (HEMs), offer a versatile platform for catalysis by leveraging entropy-stabilized solid solutions with tunable compositions, lattice structures, and electronic properties. While exsolution–dissolution of metal species in crystalline HEOs has emerged as a promising strategy for reversible active sites regeneration, the dynamic behaviour of HEOs possessing amorphous nature remains under-explored, particularly the difference with crystalline counterparts. In this work, we systematically investigate the architecture-dependent exsolution–dissolution behavior of HEOs by comparing a crystalline-phase HEO (c-HEO) and an amorphous-phase HEO (a-HEO), both comprising Ni, Mg, Cu, Zn, and Co as principal metal elements. Using a combination of in situ variable-temperature X-ray diffraction (XRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), electron microscopy, and in situ CO diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (CO-DRIFTS), the structural evolution of the two HEO phases under redox conditions was elucidated. Both materials exhibit reversible exsolution of metallic species or alloys in reducing environments, followed by re-incorporation into the host lattice upon oxidation. Remarkably, the a-HEO demonstrates more facile and dynamic self-healing behavior, with alloy exsolution and dissolution occurring under milder conditions because of its enhanced reducibility and structural disorder. This study provides critical insights into the design of next-generation regenerable catalysts based on amorphous HEOs, highlighting the role of phase structure in governing reversible metal-site formation dynamics and catalytic performance.

Wang, Qingju [Univ. of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN (U↗
DOE OSTI2024

Negative thermal expansion coefficient and amorphization in defective 4H-SiC

This paper presents thermal expansion coefficient (TEC) and amorphization in 4H-SiC containing point defects at different concentrations. We considered vacancy defects, interstitial defects, and Frenkel pair defects and investigated the thermomechanical response of the lattice over a wide range of temperatures using classical molecular dynamics simulations. The results show that 4H-SiC with vacancy defects exhibits a negative TEC above a critical defect density of around 9% (irrespective of the temperature). With interstitial defects, it exhibits a positive TEC (regardless of the defect density), and with Frenkel pair defects it shows a transition from positive TEC to negative TEC for a defect density greater than 8%. The coupling between temperature-induced expansion and defect-introduced stress in the lattice forms the mechanistic basis for the observed variation in TEC. Furthermore, the specific heat decreases rapidly with an increase in defect density at room temperature, with the highest sensitivity of the lattice observed for the Frenkel pair defects followed by interstitial defects and then by vacancy defects. Finally, these findings highlight the critical implications of defects on thermal expansion behavior of 4H-SiC with applications in radiation environments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Pressure-driven density match nucleates metastable r8 phases from amorphous Si and Ge

The pressure–temperature phase behavior of covalent disordered solids such as amorphous silicon and germanium is complex. Questions remain on possible glass transitions, on polyamorphism via amorphous–amorphous transitions, on connections with liquid–liquid transitions, on structure-behavior relationships, and on their potential as precursor for novel methods for material discovery. Here we demonstrate experimentally the nucleation of a metastable, four-fold coordinated rhombohedral r8 phase from pure amorphous silicon and germanium upon room temperature compression at pressures below 10 GPa. Accompanying theory reveals a strong pressure-driven distortion of the bond angle transforming the starting tetrahedral low-density amorphous network to a distorted four-fold coordinated medium-density state. This state is of lower density than metallic high-density networks, resembles the crystalline r8 phase and initiates its nucleation. Our finding shows that polyamorphism is not the only possible transformation mode for these amorphous solids and that instead nucleation of interesting functional phases at potentially useful pressures is possible. Such novel access modes to metastable structures are critical for future exploitability and could be useful for other tetrahedral materials including carbon, where the related (bc8) post-diamond phase remains elusive. Our observed density match between an amorphous and a metastable crystalline phase clearly allows for a new phase transition pathway, while corresponding theory demonstrates how carefully validated atomistic simulations can guide prediction, discovery and synthesis of novel material structures.

Materials discovery↗
DOE OSTI2025

An energetic link between order and strength in metals: A nanocrystalline strength limit in high-entropy alloys and intermetallic compounds

The metallurgy and materials communities have long understood and exploited fundamental links between chemical and structural ordering in metallic solids to tailor their mechanical properties. We extend these ideas to include prediction of the nanocrystalline strength limit in high-entropy alloys and intermetallic compounds, where a breakdown occurs in the classical Hall-Petch strengthening behavior. The highest reported strength achievable through alloying has rapidly climbed and given rise to new classifications of materials with extraordinary properties, with a notable case being nanocrystalline metals. High-entropy alloys (chemically disordered, concentrated solid solutions) and intermetallic compounds are two boundary cases of how tailored order can be used to manipulate mechanical behavior. Here, we show that the complex electronic-structure mechanisms governing the peak strength of alloys and pure metals can be reduced to a few physically meaningful parameters based on their atomic arrangements and used – with no fitting parameters – to predict the maximum strength of these materials. This includes a generalized energy-based accounting for the degree of structural and chemical ordering that allows for rapid and reasonably accurate prediction of peak strength (validated in the nanocrystalline limit) as a function of temperature. Predictions of maximum strength based on the activation energy (with all materials properties derived from DFT calculations or experiments) for a stress-driven transition to an amorphous state is shown to accurately describe the breakdown in Hall-Petch behavior at the smallest crystallite sizes for pure metals, intermetallic compounds, high-entropy alloys, and metallic glasses. Further, this activation energy is also shown to be directly proportional to interstitial electronic charge density, which is a good predictor of ductility, stiffness (moduli), and phase stability in high-entropy alloys and solid metals generally. The proposed framework suggests the possibility of coupling ordering and intrinsic strength to mechanisms like dislocation nucleation, hydrogen embrittlement, and transport properties, such as through correlations between the activation energies for amorphization with stacking-fault and grain boundary energies. It additionally opens the prospect for greatly accelerated structural materials design and development to address materials challenges limiting more sustainable and efficient use of energy.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Composition, Activity, and Stability of IrO x Oxygen Evolution Reaction Electrocatalysts

The oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is integral to several electrochemical energy conversion and storage technologies, including carbon dioxide reduction to value added fuels, nitrogen reduction to ammonia, reversible fuel cells, rechargeable metal−air batteries, and water electrolysis to produce hydrogen. Iridium oxide (IrO x ) is widely recognized as the benchmark OER catalyst for acidic environments. Despite widespread use of IrO x catalysts, most notably in proton-exchange membrane water electrolyzers (PEMWEs), a comprehensive understanding of the physicochemical properties of commercial catalysts and the impact of these properties on both the activity and stability of these catalysts is lacking. Here, we study commercial IrO x catalysts with different physicochemical properties, three nominally considered amorphous and three rutile, to elucidate how structural and compositional variations affect OER activity and stability. Utilizing standardized aqueous electrochemical protocols, time-resolved dissolution quantification using inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry, and physicochemical characterization, including multiple synchrotron X-ray techniques, we systematically correlate catalyst properties with OER performance and degradation behavior aided by principal component analysis (PCA). Our results demonstrate the general trend of amorphous IrO x having higher intrinsic activity but limited stability and crystalline rutile IrO 2 having lower activity but enhanced stability against dissolution. The trends within the amorphous and rutile catalyst groups correlate with inherent material properties, including phase composition and structure, crystallinity, particle size, surface area, and surface structure/chemistry. Notably, we identify a rutile catalyst with the largest crystallite/ domain sizes, moderate surface area, a small fraction of hydrous phase, and a favorable pore structure (trimodal distributions of pore sizes ranging from 2−5 nm) that exhibits the best balance between activity and stability among the six catalysts studied here. These findings illustrate a fundamental structure-governed trade-off between activity and stability and highlight the critical role of surface chemistry modification and structure engineering in IrO x catalyst optimization.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Identification of the glassy state in nanoparticles by transmission electron microscopy

Identification of amorphous phases in nanoparticles by atomic-resolution transmission electron microscopy (TEM) requires analyses such as tilt-angle-dependent TEM imaging and single-nanoparticle electron diffraction, rather than relying on a single TEM image. Here, the disordered structures of amorphous nanoparticles offer unique atomic configurations and properties that differ from the properties of their crystalline counterparts. These characteristics have motivated the exploration of such materials for mechanical, sensing and catalytic applications. In addition, the formation of amorphous metal nanoparticles is an important endeavour to understand the process of vitrification and the nature of the glassy state. Atomic-resolution transmission electron microscopy (TEM) is increasingly being used as a tool for characterizing structures of nanoparticles produced by vitrification. In this Comment, we discuss the pitfalls of using TEM for ascertaining whether nanoparticles are amorphous. We also make recommendations of best practices.

Alcorn, Francis M. [Sandia National Laboratories (↗
DOE OSTI2026

Doping Metallic Grain Boundaries to Control Atomic Structure and Damage Tolerance

Grain boundaries often act as sites for crack and void nucleation during plastic deformation of metallic materials. While it is known that grain boundary character and structure can greatly influence this damage nucleation process, the current level of control over such details is limited. The objective of this project was to obtain a fundamental understanding of how metallic grain boundary structure can be controlled through intelligent doping, with the idea of inducing planned amorphous grain boundary phases or complexions. The effect of amorphous complexion structure on dislocation accommodation mechanisms was studied, to improve the field’s understanding of damage nucleation at a promising type of interface. Different microstructural descriptors were studied, as grain boundaries can have large variations and complexity of local structure, and influence the mechanical damage resistance of these features was tested. Nanocrystalline systems that contain amorphous grain boundary complexions were prioritized, as these have more extreme variations in interfacial structure and damage tolerance, with an emphasis on isolating the importance of complexion population (type, thickness, etc.), network topology, local structure, and local chemistry. This research used a combination of computational, experimental, and characterization techniques to isolate and understand the importance of nanoscale grain boundary structure and interfacial chemistry. Amorphous grain boundary complexions were found to clearly increase a material’s resistance to mechanical damage, with the local distribution of structural short-range order within the complexions found to be an important descriptor for damage and the proposed focus of future work in this area.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Spectroscopy-guided discovery of three-dimensional structures of disordered materials with diffusion models

Spectroscopy techniques such as x-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) provide valuable insights into the atomic structures of materials, yet the inverse prediction of precise structures from spectroscopic data remains a formidable challenge. In this study, we introduce a framework that combines generative artificial intelligence models with XANES spectroscopy to predict three-dimensional atomic structures of disordered systems, using amorphous carbon (a-C) as a model system. In this work, we introduce a new framework based on the diffusion model, a recent generative machine learning method, to predict 3D structures of disordered materials from a target property. For demonstration, we apply the model to identify the atomic structures of a-C as a representative material system from the target XANES spectra. We show that conditional generation guided by XANES spectra reproduces key features of the target structures. Furthermore, we show that our model can steer the generative process to tailor atomic arrangements for a specific XANES spectrum. Finally, our generative model exhibits a remarkable scale-agnostic property, thereby enabling generation of realistic, large-scale structures through learning from a small-scale dataset (i.e. with small unit cells). Our work represents a significant stride in bridging the gap between materials characterization and atomic structure determination; in addition, it can be leveraged for materials discovery in exploring various material properties as targeted.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Characterization of lateral amorphous selenium photodetectors for low-photon and VUV detection at cryogenic temperatures

The performance of amorphous selenium (a-Se) as a cryogenic photodetector material is evaluated through a series of experiments using laterally structured devices operated in a custom optical test stand. These studies investigate the response of a-Se detectors to low-photon fluxes at high electric fields near avalanche conditions, the linearity of the photoconductive response over a wide dynamic range and the direct detection of narrowband 130 nm vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) illumination. At 87 K, matched-filter analysis shows reliable single-shot detection with efficiencies ≥80% and area under the curve (AUC) ≥ 0.85 using as few as ∼ 6800 incident 401 nm photons, corresponding to ∼ 3400 photons within field-active regions after accounting for geometric constraints. Measurements are performed at cryogenic temperatures using calibrated photon fluxes derived from a silicon photomultiplier reference and a characterized optical filter stack. Additional experiments using a tellurium-doped a-Se (a-SeTe) device explore the material's behavior under identical test conditions and demonstrate that avalanche is achievable in a-SeTe at cryogenic temperatures. The results demonstrate reproducible low-noise operation, VUV sensitivity and field-dependent gain behavior in a lateral a-Se architecture, representing the first reported observation of avalanche multiplication in laterally structured a-Se and a-SeTe devices at cryogenic temperatures. These findings support the potential integration of laterally structured a-Se devices into next-generation pixelated liquid-argon time projection chambers (TPCs) requiring scalable, high-field-compatible photon detection systems.

Amorphous selenium↗
DOE OSTI2024

Harnessing graph convolutional neural networks for identification of glassy states in metallic glasses

Graph Convolutional Neural Networks (GCNNs) have emerged as powerful tools for analyzing materials. In this study, we employ GCNNs to examine structural characteristics of CuZr metallic glasses (MGs) and identify their states. We use molecular dynamics to simulate the quenching process of CuZr, using cooling rates ranging from 10 9 to 10 15 K/s, to produce six unique glassy states. For each state, we create a dataset comprising 1,800 distinct samples. We evaluate the effectiveness of various GCNNs, including Graph Attention Neural Network (GANN), Graph Sample and AggreGatE (GraphSAGE), Graph Isomorphism Network (GIN), and Relational Graph Convolutional Neural Network (RGCN). GANN and GraphSAGE demonstrate comparable performance, achieving an overall accuracy of 81% in classifying the MG states. Furthermore, these results underscore the potential of GCNNs to detect subtle structural variances in disordered materials and point to broader application of deep learning in the analysis of MGs and other amorphous substances.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗