Comparison of URANS and LES Predictions for the Open Phase of the OECD NEA CSNI Fluid Structure Interaction CFD Benchmark
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Transportable microreactors pose a unique shielding challenge compared with conventional reactors. Many vendors are seeking to transport a microreactor to a site, operate it for a number of years, and then transport it to a secondary site. This involves ensuring the reactor has sufficient shielding during operations and post-irradiation transportation to ensure the safety of those around it, all while ensuring it can be transported via traditional means. This work examines the use of a nuclear grade sandwich composite (NGSC) which seeks to combine the reactor pressure vessel and biological shielding into a single unit. Through this work, it was determined that the NGSC was sufficient to adequately reduce neutron and gamma current exiting the structure to warrant further investigation as a potential shielding option for microreactors.
This report summarizes efforts performed during Fiscal Year 2022 to develop capabilities for modeling structural component degradation in support of the U.S. Department of Energy's Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation Program. These efforts were centered around development of capabilities for the Grizzly code. Efforts focused both on foundational engineering-scale analysis capabilities for damage and shell formulations and on material-scale tools for accounting for irradiation effects in Grade 91 steel. A major outcome of this effort was the development of a general-purpose tool for nonlocal averaging of material properties, which enabled nonlocal damage models. In addition, the applicability of the shell elements in MOOSE has been expanded to allow modeling a wider range of component geometries and using a wide variety of material models. For irradiation effects on materials, a previously developed cluster dynamics model for light water reactor pressure vessel steels has been adapted for application to Grade 91 alloy. This work builds on prior efforts to build a flexible, capable code for addressing a variety of aging and component performance issues in nuclear power plant structural components.
The nature of the high-lying final levels of the 96 Y gs β decay, one of the three most important contributors to the high-energy reactor antineutrino spectrum, has been investigated in high-resolution γ-ray spectroscopy following the β decay as well as in a campaign of inelastic photon scattering experiments. The comprehensive approach establishes 1 - levels associated with the Pygmy Dipole Resonance as high-lying final levels in the β decay. Branching ratios extracted from β decay complement photon scattering and allow the absolute E1 excitation strength to be determined for levels populated in both reactions. The combined data represents a comprehensive approach to the wavefunction of the 1 - levels below the Qβ value, which are investigated in the Quasiparticle Phonon Model. The calculations reveal that the components populated in β decay contribute only with small amplitudes to the complex wavefunction of these 1 - levels. A comparison of the β decay results to data from total absorption γ -ray spectroscopy demonstrates a good agreement between both measurements.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), in collaboration with Flibe Energy, demonstrated the fabrication of metal organic frameworks (MOFs) into engineered beads to manage off-gases released from advanced reactors, including molten salt reactors. Based on the commercial availability and easy to synthesis at scale, PNNL down-selected two MOF sorbents known as CuBTC and UiO-67. The sorbents were synthesized, characterized, and fabricated into mechanically robust engineered beads (composites) using wet granulation method using polymer as a binder. Further, MOF powders and and mechanically robust composites were exposed to gamma radiation using Co-60 source and characterized irradiated MOFs to demonstrate the structural stability. Among the two MOF sorbents identified, the CuBTC MOF was shown to be very promising for noble gas management at low temperature (193 K) compared to UiO-67 MOF. The high adsorption capacity of the synthesized composites was correlated to the high surface area and pore volume of the CuBTC MOF. Both MOFs retain structural integrity and long-range order even after exposure to 1000 kGy of radiation.
Nuclear microreactors (MRs) offer unique advantages, such as rapid deployment, potability, low maintenance requirements, and operational flexibility. Their compact size makes them a promising solution for decentralized power generation, particularly in remote areas, military bases, and disaster-stricken regions. However, MRs face challenges, including unutilized fissile material at the end of life, economic inefficiency, increased heavy metal (HM) waste complicating disposal, and the accumulation of plutonium (Pu) with high 239 Pu concentrations raising proliferation risks. Here, this study investigated the neutronics feasibility of a novel three-stage fuel cycle where discharged HM from MRs is recycled and burned in light water reactors and sodium-cooled fast reactors. This approach converts discharged HM into valuable fuel, enhancing the efficiency of MR deployments while improving the safeguardability of their final waste products. Neutronics analysis demonstrated that the safety characteristics of reactor designs in each stage were minimally impacted by the proposed cycle. For two representative MR designs, a fast-spectrum MR with solid pellet fuel and a thermal-spectrum MR with TRISO (TRi-structural-ISOtropic) fuel compacts, the proposed fuel cycle reduced the uranium disposal mass flow rate by ~60%, decreased the 235 U enrichment of the discharge fuel to ~1 wt%, eliminated plutonium disposal, and increased the cumulative fuel burnup to ~580 gigawatt-day per metric ton of initial heavy metal (GWd/t-iHM) or 60% fissions per initial metal atom. Despite the significant differences between the two MR designs, the performance and infrastructure requirements of the developed fuel cycles were remarkably similar, indicating its generalizability to a broader class of MRs.
Seismic isolation can mitigate earthquake demands on safety-class equipment and is being considered for application to some advanced nuclear reactors. For tall, slender vessels that could represent an advanced reactor, a steam generator or a heat exchanger, mid-height seismic isolation has been shown to be beneficial and practical. Here, this paper focuses on numerical modeling of a mid-height isolated tall, slender vessel with two primary goals 1) investigate and quantify the benefits of mid-height seismic isolation for a range of support structure stiffnesses, isolation systems, and seismic inputs, and 2) provide analysis and design recommendations for isolation of safety-class equipment. Results of response-history analysis were in good agreement with experimental measurements and demonstrated that mid-height isolation can substantially reduce seismic demands on tall, slender vessels for a range of support structure stiffnesses, isolation systems, and seismic inputs. Importantly, the reductions in horizontal spectral accelerations in the mid-height isolated vessel from the non-isolated condition were not affected by the stiffness of the support structure. Recommendations are made for analysis and design of isolated equipment and testing of isolators used for equipment protection in nuclear facilities, which are also applicable to other industries.
Abstract – The Gas-Cooled Reactor deployment effort in the United States is a collaboration between the US government and private vendors. The US Department of Energy sponsors the qualification of fuels, materials, and analysis methods that exploit the capabilities of the national laboratories (mainly Idaho, Oak Ridge, and Argonne) to generate the fundamental fuel, material, and core behavior data needed to support design and licensing efforts by vendors in general. Private HTR vendors provide input to the R&D program and engage in the design of the systems, structures, and components that are unique to their design concepts. Their plant design all exploit the properties and behavior of the TRISO fuel, graphite, and alloys being tested in the DOE qualification programs. This paper will summarize the goals and recent progress of the US Gas-Cooled Reactor Program.
Additive manufacturing enables user-defined control of the compositional complexity, opening new design spaces for complex concentrated alloys (CCAs). Refractory CCAs may offer enhanced performance in the divertor region of a fusion reactor environment where plasma-facing materials will be subject to high temperatures, low energy He and D particles, and 14 MeV neutrons. In this work, specimens with the nominal composition of NbTaMoTi, NbTaMo, NbTaTi, and NbTa were fabricated via directed energy deposition (DED) then bombarded with 40 eV He ions to a fluence of 2x10 26 m −2 at ∼ 1000 K. Post irradiation, the surface morphology and composition were examined with electron microscopy and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy to offer information on the spatial distribution of surface nano-structuring. Sub-surface He bubbles driving the nano-structuring were examined with electron microscopy techniques. Analysis indicates the local composition directly influences the He bubble and tendril size, while the region with the highest complexity showed the shortest nano-structuring. Molecular Dynamics simulations complement the experimental results, showing comparable helium bubble growth and migration as a function of compositional complexity. This work demonstrates the compositional dependence of surface nanostructure formation of compositionally complex alloys, important for future design of complex plasma facing materials in fusion reactors.
This study evaluates reactor physics aspects of the proposed High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) permanent beryllium reflector number 5 design. HFIR is a pressurized, light water–cooled, and beryllium reflected research reactor that operates at 85 MW for cycle lengths of approximately 24 to 26 days. A new permanent reflector design is highly desirable for increased versatility in irradiation experiments, to arrange the vertical experiment facilities (VXFs) to minimize their impact on neutron scattering if loaded with neutronabsorbing experiments, to enhance reflector thermal-structural-hydraulic performance, and to simplify the complex fabrication process. The current number 4 and concept number 5 reflectors have 22 and 28 VXFs, respectively, and are modeled and analyzed in this study with the MCNP5 and SCALE 6.1.3 nuclear simulation codes.
The effect of controlled nitrogen additions was evaluated on the mechanical properties of T-111 (Ta-8W-2Hf) fuel pin cladding material proposed for use in a lithium-cooled nuclear reactor concept. Additions of 80 to 1125 ppm nitrogen resulted in increased strengthening of T-111 tubular section test specimens at temperatures of 25 to 1200 C. Homogeneous distributions of up to 500 ppm nitrogen did not seriously decrease tensile ductility. Both single and two-phase microstructures, with hafnium nitride as the second phase, were evaluated in this study.
The most efficient and promising operational regime for the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor tokamak is the high-confinement mode. In this regime, however, periodic relaxations of the plasma edge can occur. These edge-localized modes pose a threat to the integrity of the fusion device. Here we reveal the strong impact of energetic ions on the spatio-temporal structure of edge-localized modes in tokamaks using nonlinear hybrid kinetic–magnetohydrodynamic simulations. A resonant interaction between the fast ions at the plasma edge and the electromagnetic perturbations from the edge-localized mode leads to an energy and momentum exchange. Energetic ions modify, for example, the amplitude, frequency spectrum and crash timing of edge-localized modes. The simulations reproduce some observations that feature abrupt and large edge-localized mode crashes. The results indicate that, in the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor, a strong interaction between the fusion-born alpha particles and ions from neutral beam injection, a main heating and fast particle source, is expected with predicted edge-localized mode perturbations. This work advances the understanding of the physics underlying edge-localized mode crashes in the presence of energetic particles and highlights the importance of including energetic ion kinetic effects in the optimization of edge-localized mode control techniques and regimes that are free of such modes.
This report documents the microstructural and surface characterization of two high-fluence baffle-former bolts (BFBs) harvested from a commercial pressurized water reactor (PWR) after nearly four decades of service. These bolts experienced extreme conditions including high neutron fluence, elevated temperatures, corrosive primary water, and sustained mechanical loads, all of which contribute to degradation mechanisms such as irradiation-assisted stress corrosion cracking (IASCC). Using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), the study assessed bulk and near-surface microstructures, grain boundary characteristics, and in-service oxide layers. The results revealed significant differences between bolts exposed to 41 dpa and 29 dpa, including differences in recrystallization extent, deformation structures, and oxidation morphology. These findings establish critical baseline data for integration with advanced synchrotron-based high-energy X-ray microscopy (HEXM) and computational crystal plasticity models. Ultimately, the work supports improved mechanistic understanding and predictive capability regarding the long-term performance of reactor core internal components.
The grain structure of the silicon carbide (SiC) layer in tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) fuels has commonly been qualified in fuel specifications based on a qualitative comparison to visual standards to ensure undesirable microstructure are not produced. This approach is inherently dependent on subjective judgement and provides limited data for analysis or comparison. An alternative method to rapidly quantify (i.e., provide a numeric measure of) the grain structure of the SiC layer in TRISO fuels has been developed. This method relies on the identification of silicon carbide grain boundaries based on brightness variation in backscattered electron (BSE) images through the application of automated image processing algorithms. The speed with which the requisite BSE imaging and analysis may be completed enables the practical use of this method on an industrial scale as a part of qualifying TRISO fuel to meet a given specification on silicon carbide grain structure, which is an important parameter for TRISO fuel performance. The method is benchmarked by comparison to prior Electron-Backscattered Diffraction (EBSD) results for TRISO particles from the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) program.
Heat transfer across nuclear fuels and structural interfaces is an important factor for evaluating the performance of nuclear power systems. Specifically, heat generated as nuclear fuel fissions must be transported through the cladding material and through the reactor to reach the steam turbine for power generation. As new microreactor designs emerge, maximizing the efficiency of this heat transfer process becomes crucial to make them commercially viable. This article examines thermal diffusivity and gap conductance in uranium nitride (UN) fuel and Zircaloy-4 (Zry4) cladding using light flash analysis (LFA). Thermal diffusivity measurements were made on monolithic UN pellets and Zry4 exposed to carbon at peak operating temperatures of microreactors and show that carbon ingress has a minimal effect on thermal diffusivity when compared with identical materials not exposed to carbon. Evaluation of gap conductance at the UN-Zry4 interface was done using one-dimensional two-layer thermal transport models as a function of applied pressure. Here the results show that increasing pressure on the UN-Zry4 interface leads to gains in gap conductance per unit area in fuel-cladding assemblies at microreactor operating temperatures. While many other variables are expected to influence UN-Zry4 interfacial gap conductance (e.g. contact surface roughness, porosity, localized heating, environmental gas pressure), the work offers a demonstration of using a conventional LFA apparatus to determine this parameter at elevated temperatures.
This evaluation was prepared at the request of DOE-FES and expands on an earlier evaluation prepared by Wilson, Wiffen and Keiser in 2015 (attached as Appendices A and B). Additional useful information for materials in fission molten salt reactor systems that use FLiBe can be found in a prior NRC report [Busby 2019]. The purpose of this report is to review the considerations that will determine the fusion blanket structural materials that will be suitable for use in a FLiBe breeder-coolant fusion power plant (FPP). Identifying a fusion-relevant structural material that is sufficiently compatible with FLiBe is a key issue to be addressed. The constraints and trade-offs made in structural materials selection include the usual power generation requirements such as mechanical properties, fabricability and durability, which assumes reasonable compatibility with the working fluid. For an FPP, additional constraints include neutron economy (breeding ratio), resistance to irradiation damage and low activation (i.e. waste disposal) characteristics.
A program is presented which was aimed at determining the feasibility of using high temperature reactions of alkali metals and silicon halides to produce low cost solar-grade silicon. Experiments are being conducted to evaluate product separation and collection processes, measure heat release parameters for scaling purposes, and determine the effects of the reactants and/or products on materials of reactor construction. During the current reporting period, the results of heat release experiments were used to design and construct a new type of thick-wall graphite reactor to produce larger quantities of silicon. A reactor test facility was constructed. Material compatibility tests were performed for Na in contact with graphite and several coated graphites. All samples were rapidly degraded at T = 1200K, while samples retained structural strength at 1700K. Pyrolytic graphite coatings cracked and separated from substances in all cases.
Multi-principal component transition metal (TM) diborides represent a class of high-entropy ceramics (HECs) that have received considerable interest in recent years owing to their promising properties for extreme environment applications that include thermal/ environmental barriers, hypersonic vehicles, turbine engines, and next-generation nuclear reactors. While the addition of chemical disorder through the random distribution of TM elements on the cation sublattice has offered opportunities to tailor elastic stiffness and hardness, the effects of irradiationinduced structural damage on the physical properties of these complex materials have remained largely unexplored. To this end, changes in the hardness and elastic moduli of a high-entropy TM diboride (Hf0.2Nb0.2Ta0.2Ti0.2Zr0.2)B2 and three of its quaternary subsets following irradiation with 10 MeV gold (Au) ions to fluences of up to 6 × 10^15 Au cm-2 are investigated at the micrometer and sub-micrometer length-scales via the dispersion of laser-generated surface acoustic waves (SAW) and nanoindentation, respectively. The nanoindentation measurements show that the TM diborides exhibit an initial increase in hardness following irradiation with energetic Au ions, with a subsequent decrease in hardness following further irradiation. One quaternary composition, (Hf1/3Ta1/3Ti1/3)B2, exhibits a notable exception to the trend and continues to exhibit an increase in hardness with ion irradiation fluence. Although differences in the absolute values of the effective elastic moduli obtained from the measured SAW dispersion and nanoindentation are observed (and attributed to microstructural variations at the measurement length-scale), both techniques yield similar trends in the form of an initial reduction and subsequent saturation in the elastic modulus with increasing ion irradiation fluence. The quaternary TM diboride (Hf1/3Ta1/3Ti1/3)B2 again exhibits a departure from this trend. The high-entropy TM diboride (Hf0.2Nb0.2Ta0.2Ti0.2Zr0.2)B2 exhibits the greatest recovery in hardness and modulus when irradiated to high ion fluences following initial changes at low fluence, indicating superior resistance to radiation-induced damage over its quaternary counterparts. Opportunities for designing HECs with superior hardness and modulus for enhanced radiation resistance (compared to their single constituent counterparts) by tailoring chemical disorder and bond character in the lattice are discussed.