Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Space manufacturing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 145 records · Page 8
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

Multiphysics Design Optimization and Additive Manufacturing of Nuclear Components (Final CRADA Report - Executive Summary)

Westinghouse Electric Company (WEC) actively participated in the advancement of the nuclear fuel and reactor design space and requested the help of Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) in the creation of a new design tool set. This report details the creation of a collection of software tool sets that are linked together to collectively assist WEC design engineers in developing novel ideas outside the normal scope of traditional nuclear fuel and reactor design formulas. Specifically, Siemens HEEDS, a design space exploration and parametric optimization software, monitored and changed parameters in a collection of softwares to meet the team’s objective. The HEEDS parametric optimization method, SHERPA, was developed to control the Siemens NX CAD platform to adjust the native CAD of a hexahedral spacer grid. This new geometry can be used to execute a topological design optimization by the NX Topology software add-in. The resulting geometry is additively manufacturable. This topological optimization occurred twice—once on the spacer grid’s spring, and once on the dimple geometry. These new geometries were imported by Siemens’ STAR-CCM+, a multiphysics structural and fluid dynamic computational solver in which the spring geometry is deflected to match the rod insertion configuration. Along with the dimple geometry, this new deflected spring was used to complete a hydraulic assessment of a single-unit cell comprising one rod, one spring, and two dimples. The HEEDS SHERPA algorithm ranks the design based on the final mass of the unit cell and the hydraulic pressure drop performance. The ORNL team demonstrated the ability to use this software and provided engineering judgement to apply modern aerospace aerodynamic design. The effort has been focused on thinking outside the conventional design space and redesigning a spacer grid to perform beyond the WEC set objectives. Furthermore, the ORNL team also demonstrated that the HEEDS optimization routine can independently develop a design that meets the WEC design goals. Although these designs were at a low technology readiness level, their demonstration confirmed the team’s capability to create novel advanced nuclear concepts.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Enabling In-Core Strain Measurement: Printed Sensors for Advanced Reactors

Advances in nuclear energy systems require an improved understanding of fuels, cladding, and structural materials; however, the extreme environmental conditions at irradiation test facilities often limit mechanical property evaluation to post-irradiation examination. In-situ monitoring techniques can accelerate materials qualification by providing direct insight into real-time material behavior during irradiation testing. Additively manufactured (AM) strain gauges offer a compact, material-compatible alternative to commercial sensors, particularly where space constraints, attachment limitations, or material compatibility requirements complicate conventional sensor use. This poster presents an overview of the development and testing of AM strain gauges in nuclear-relevant environments, demonstrating their potential to enhance structural health monitoring capabilities during irradiation experiments.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Unveiling Atomistic Mechanisms Governing Additive Manufacturing Processability and Mechanical Behavior of a Refractory Complex Concentrated Alloy

Extending the concept of complex concentrated alloys (CCAs) to the refractory alloys (solidus temperature over 2000 °C) space potentially facilitates the design of lightweight structural alloys with service temperatures that exceed those of Ni and Co‐based alloys. However, the room and elevated temperature tensile properties of the current refractory‐CCAs (R‐CCAs) are inferior to those of the Ni/Co‐based alloys. Furthermore, the manufacturing scalability of R‐CCAs remains challenging, in that cracks are prevalent in all R‐CCAs when processed using near‐net shape manufacturing processes, such as fusion‐based additive manufacturing (F‐BAM). Still, mechanisms governing the poor F‐BAM processability of R‐CCAs remain unexplored. Here, to this end, this work unveils the atomistic mechanisms underlying F‐BAM process‐induced cracking in a NbTiTaMoHfZrC R‐CCA. The implications of light elements’ presence for intrinsic ductility and grain boundary cohesion, and subsequently for F‐BAM processability and mechanical behavior, are revealed. Leveraging the insights, we accomplish what is, to the best of the knowledge, the first instance of crack‐free F‐BAM processing of any R‐CCA. Additionally, the R‐CCA exhibits over 20% tensile ductility and ≈160 MPa tensile yield strength at 1200 °C. In addition to facilitating the design of lightweight R‐CCAs, findings enable scalable manufacturing of these ultra‐high temperature alloys for structural applications.

Refractory alloys↗
DOE OSTI2022

Compressive properties of silicone Bouligand structures

Abstract This article presents an examination of silicone, Bouligand lattices in compression. Appearing frequently in biological organisms and manufacturing design, Bouligand structures comprise layers of parallel strands or fibers oriented in a helical fashion. They can exhibit exceptional fracture resistance when composed of rigid or composite materials. The behavior of elastomeric Bouligand structures, however, is less well understood. Additively manufactured (AM) elastomeric lattices have applications in stress mitigation, medical devices, and soft robotics. This article demonstrates that Bouligand structures are a useful addition to the design space of AM elastomers. By adjusting the layer-rotation parameters, lattice stress can increase by more than 300% without altering the porosity. Additionally, we introduce path length metrics that help explain the observed relationship between layer rotation and compression response. Impact statement Additive manufacturing (AM) continues to push the boundary of manufacturable structures and enhance the ability to robustly design for specific properties and behaviors. The more we understand the design space of a novel AM microstructure, the greater its application range. In this article, we describe the mechanical behavior of helicoidal, elastomeric lattices and introduce path length metrics to help explain their stress response. We show that these structures can exhibit a large range of mechanical behaviors in compression, making them well suited for applications such as stress mitigation and impact absorption. Additionally, the path length metrics could become useful design tools and may be applicable to a larger set of cellular structures. These findings expand our ability to rapidly design materials with highly specific and customizable properties to meet the needs of modern engineering challenges. Graphical abstract

Van Meerbeek, I. M. (ORCID:000000021258132X)↗
DOE OSTI2021

Data Science Techniques, Assumptions, and Challenges in Alloy Clustering and Property Prediction

Data analytics methods have been increasingly applied to understanding materials chemistry, processing due to the manufacturing approach, and uni-axial and cyclic property relationships in the highly complex space of alloy design. There are several benefits to applying data analytics to this space, including the ability to manage non-linearities in the responses of the alloy attributes and the resulting mechanical properties. However, key difficulties in applying and understanding the results of data analytics include the often lack of reported assumptions and data processing steps necessary to improve interpretation and reproducibility in derived results. In this work, the methods used to generate clustering and correlation analyses for experimental 9% Cr ferritic-martensitic steel data were investigated and the resulting implications for mechanical property predictions were assessed. This work uses principal component analysis, partitioning around medoids, t-SNE, and k-means clustering to investigate trends in composition, processing and microstructure information with creep and tensile properties, building on work done previously using a smaller version of the same dataset. The initial assumptions, preprocessing steps and methods are investigated and outlined in order to depict the fine level of detail required to convey the steps taken to process data and produce analytical results. Here, the variations in the resulting analyses are explored due to the influence of new and more varied data.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Three-dimensional continuum point cloud method for large deformation and its verification

This study presents a strong form based meshfree collocation method, which is named Continuum Point Cloud Method, to solve nonlinear field equations derived from classical mechanics for deformed bodies in three-dimensional Euclidean space. The method and its implementation are benchmarked against a nonlinear vector field using manufactured solutions. The analysis of mechanical fields firstly focuses on the study of St. Venant Kirchhoff and compressible neo-Hookean materials. Results for various initial boundary value problems are presented, including benchmark cases involving unidirectional tension and simple shear. Subsequently, the study concludes with an analysis of a displacement-controlled simulation of a compressible neo-Hookean material, specifically a bar that is pulled to 50% of its original length and rotated 90°. The pure tension case yields a 1.5% error in displacement between computed and expected values and a combined tension and torsion loading case provides further insight into material behavior under complex loading conditions. The resulting normal axial and transverse stress-strain curves are also presented. Lastly, the consistency and robustness of the proposed nonlinear numerical schemes are successfully demonstrated through various numerical experiments.

Compressible neo-Hookean materials↗
DOE OSTI2023

Predictive Modeling of Electrodeposition in a Single Pore Flow-Through Electrode: From Electronucleation to Coating Thickness Uniformity

The emergence of advanced manufacturing methods capable of producing porous three-dimensional structures has expanded the design space for next-generation functional components. The ability to fabricate ordered 3D foams for use in electrocatalysis reactors has increased the need for controlled deposition of catalytic metals onto porous support materials, such as carbon. However, there is a lack of clear design guidelines for electrodeposition onto 3D substrates, due to the geometric complexity and multi-scale nature of the problem. Furthermore, electro-nucleation phenomena are often overlooked in macro-scale models of current distribution during deposition. Here, a graphite flow-through electrode (FTE) is used as a model system for copper deposition within a single pore. Potential distributions and electro-nucleation phenomena are coupled in a continuum level model by incorporating nucleation size and density as a function of overpotential, determined experimentally using in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM). The model predictions are validated by measuring the coating uniformity in the pore using micro-computed X-ray tomography (μCT). A scaling analysis comprising dimensionless parameters such as the Wagner number is presented. The simplified scaling relationship framework can guide the electrodeposition process and electrode design to optimize plating of porous substrates under fluid flow conditions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

Multiscale characterization and representation of variability in ceramic matrix composites

Low density, high strength, and high creep and oxidation resistance properties of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) make them an ideal choice for use in extreme environments in space and military applications. This paper presents a detailed characterization study of structural and manufacturing flaws in Carbon fiber Silicon-Carbide-Nitride matrix (C/SiNC) CMCs at different length-scales. Energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) is used for the chemical characterization of the material’s elemental constituents. High-resolution multiscale graphs obtained from scanning electron microscope (SEM) and confocal laser scanning microscope (LSM) are used to characterize the distribution and morphology of defects at different length scales. This is followed by the classification and quantification of the common manufacturing defects. An image processing algorithm based on the image segmentation process is developed to quantify the variability of various scale-dependent architectural parameters. Finally, a three-dimensional stochastic representative volume element (SRVE) generation algorithm is developed to provide precise representations of material textures at multiple length scales. The developed algorithm accurately accounts for material features and flaws based on a range of multiscale structural and defects characterization results.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

CALPHAD-based Bayesian optimization to accelerate alloy discovery for high-temperature applications

Two crucial properties influencing the performance of high-temperature alloys are coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) and phase constitution. It is desirable to have alloys with low CTE, which reduces CTE mismatch with the surface oxide and the likelihood of oxide spallation. Reducing the amount of brittle intermetallic phases such as Sigma (σ) enhances alloy ductility and processability. Here, we propose a multi-objective Bayesian Optimization (BO) model to simultaneously minimize CTE (at an operational temperature of 1150 °C) and T σ (temperature when the Sigma phase completely dissolves in the metal matrix), properties which are obtained from high-throughput CALculation of PHAse Diagrams (CALPHAD). The model successfully identifies several alloys with CTE ≤ 2 × 10 –5 /K and T σ ≤ 500 °C by exploring just 7% of the nickel–chromium–cobalt–aluminum–iron (Ni–Cr–Co–Al–Fe) composition space. Such multi-objective alloy design frameworks can be used to inform additive manufacturing experiments and accelerate alloy discovery for high-temperature energy applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Embodied carbon in the U.S. manufacturing and trade

On average, one quarter of the global carbon footprint is embodied in traded goods. These emissions are a growing issue for global efforts to decarbonize the world economy. Embodied emissions in trade are not accounted for by existing greenhouse gas accounting systems. For example, countries only report their domestic carbon emissions (also known as production-based or territorial accounting) to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). If the embodied carbon in trade were accounted for and reported, the promising climate trends depicted by many countries would be negated or reversed. For example, many achievements of reducing emissions by developed countries under the Kyoto Protocol would actually appear as emissions outsourced to developing countries. Like many other developed countries, the United States is a net importer of embodied greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in trade. The goal of this study was to calculate the carbon footprint of various sectors of the U.S. economy using the latest available data and based on that, estimate the embodied carbon in certain manufacturing sector products imported and exported by the U.S. First, we conducted an input-output analysis to calculate the carbon footprint of 401 aggregate level sectors of the U.S. economy. After that, for a selected number of manufacturing subsectors /products(hereafter referred to as products),we collected their trade(import/export) data and combined that with their computed carbon footprint to estimate the embodied carbon in import and export of these products for the U.S. While we conducted the carbon footprint analysis for sectors covering the entire U.S. economy (401 sectors), we only conducted the embodied carbon in trade analysis for a few products within specific aggregate level manufacturing sectors,such as computer and electronic product manufacturing (NAICS 334), transport equipment manufacturing (NAICS 336), machinery manufacturing (NAICS 333), and chemical manufacturing (NAICS 325). It is possible to do the detailed embodied carbon analysis for all other products within the various aggregate level manufacturing sectors of the U.S. economy, but given the scope of this study and space constraint of this report, we only present the results for a few products. The results of our analysis for the selected products show the embodied carbon in trade for each product by country and also show the rankings of countries in terms of top importers and exporters of embodied carbon in trade with the U.S. Our results show that in majority of cases, the U.S. is a net importer of embodied carbon in trade. Unless consumption-based accounting is used, the U.S. and other net embodied carbon importing countries may continue to outsource their emissions to meet their climate change mitigation targets under the Paris Agreement, as observed previously with the Kyoto Protocol. Some countries reported reductions that exceeded their Kyoto targets, however, the changes in emissions embodied in imports were comparable to or larger than changes in domestic emissions. Traded emissions undermined emissions reductions in the Kyoto Protocol, and threaten to continue to do so for the Paris Agreement. New climate policies such as California’s Buy Clean act, EU’s proposed border carbon tax adjustment, as well as efforts in the private sector can help address the embodied carbon in traded products.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Material and Design Optimization of Printed Melt Wire Arrays

Recent work conducted by the Advanced Sensors and Instrumentation (ASI) program at Idaho National Laboratory resulted in the establishment of in-house capabilities for fabricating and testing new advanced manufactured sensors for measuring irradiation temperatures inside a nuclear test reactor. Though current methods of real-time temperature monitoring (e.g., thermocouples) can still be used, the complexity of the feedthroughs and attachments needed for collecting real time measurements greatly increases the experiment-related costs. On the other hand, passive monitoring techniques can be used for collecting post irradiation temperature measurements by inferring reactor temperatures, based on the melting points of well-characterized materials (i.e., standard melt wires). However, challenges have arisen due to the limited space available for including instrumentation in experiments. To resolve this issue, the ASI program expanded its temperature detection capabilities to include advance manufactured melt wires for post-irradiation temperature measurements. These melt wires can determine reactor temperatures while also accommodating space limitations in irradiation experiments. To improve performance reliability and enhance melt wire readability following irradiation, FY-22 efforts have focused on optimizing the materials used in the encapsulation and printed melt wire array. This report details the design and fabrication tasks, along with the subsequent x ray computed tomography (XCT) evaluation process. The melt wire array consisted of indium with a melting point of 157°C, indium/silver (96/4 at%) with a melting point of 219°C, and tin with a melting point of 230°C. The encapsulation disc was made of vanadium due to its low activation properties and radiation resistance when deployed in nuclear reactors. Additionally, the melt wire design consisted of a ceramic sublayer (alumina disc) to further enhance the XCT post melting images of the printed melt wires. However, when sealing the vanadium container, all three melt wires melted, reflecting the temperature limitations that must be considered when employing metal containers in the sealing process.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
DOE OSTI2021

Design Optimization for Printed Melt Wire Arrays Encapsulation

As part of the Nuclear Energy Enabling Technology (NEET) Advanced Sensor and Instrumentation (ASI) Program, Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has recently established in-house capabilities to fabricate and test new advanced-manufactured sensors for measuring peak irradiation temperature within a nuclear test reactor. Although methods of real-time temperature monitoring, such as thermocouples, may be used, the complexity of feedthroughs and attachments to collect real-time measurements greatly increases the cost of the experiment. Instead, passive monitoring techniques may be used for peak- temperature measurement that exploit the melting point of well-characterized materials (standard melt wires) to infer peak reactor temperatures. However, limited available space for instrumentation during experiments introduces an additional challenge. To accommodate this, INL has expanded its temperature- detection instrumentation capabilities to include advanced manufactured (AM) melt wires for peak irradiation temperature measurements. These melt wires can determine peak temperatures while also accommodate space limitations in irradiation experiments. In an effort to improve performance reliability of AM meltwire capabilities, a process was developed and tested to identify the significance of entrapping a high purity inert atmosphere within the packaging of printed melt wire arrays. The materials used in this study were aluminum, zinc, and tin encapsulated in high purity helium within a stainless steel (SS) 316 container. Tin, with a low melting point of approximately 230°C, Zn with a mid-melting point of approximately 420°C, and Al with a high melting point of approximately 660°C. This report describes the design, fabrication process, furnace testing and X-ray Computed Tomography (XCT) evaluation. Results show a successful outcome in creating an inert gas encapsulation and high-resolution evaluation methods.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
DOE OSTI2024

Additive manufacturing of multiscale NiFeMn multi-principal element alloys with tailored composition

Nanostructured multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) have been explored as next-generation engineering materials due to unique mechanical and functional properties which have significant advantages over traditional dilute alloys. However, the practical applications of nanostructured MPEAs are still limited due to the lack of scalable processing approaches to prepare a large quantity of nanostructured MPEAs, as well as lack of an efficient pathway for high-throughput discovery of better functional nanostructured MPEAs within their vast compositional space. Here we tackle these challenges by presenting an integrated approach by combining direct-ink-writing-based additive manufacturing, solid-state sintering, and chemical dealloying to manufacture hierarchically porous MPEAs. The hierarchical structure is comprised of macro- and micro-scale pores introduced via extrusion printing and polymer decomposition during sintering, as well as nanoscale pores formed via chemical dealloying. The macro- and micro-scale pores allow efficient dealloying of a large mass of material as the diffusion length that the corroding medium must penetrate remains at the scale of the ligaments formed after sintering (∼10 μm), despite the large volume of the 3D-printed samples. In addition, this integrated approach enables versatile control of the alloy composition via precisely tuning the ratio of elemental powders in the starting ink, thus offering a pathway for high-throughput discovery of novel functional MPEAs. As a case study, multiscale macro/micro/nanoporous NiFeMn MPEAs with three different compositions were investigated as catalysts to reduce the overpotential of oxygen evolution reaction (OER), where NiFeMn-based electrocatalysts display composition-dependent performance such that the overpotential measured at a current of 0.5 A g −1 for OER increases in the order of Ni 58 Fe 29 Mn 13 ⩽ Ni 64 Fe 26 Mn 10 < Ni 76 Fe 18 Mn 6 . This introduced manufacturing process offers new opportunities for scalable fabrication and rapid screening of nanostructured multi-component complex alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Spectrally accelerated edge and scrape-off layer gyrokinetic turbulence simulations

This paper presents the first gyrokinetic (GK) simulations of edge and scrape-off layer (SOL) turbulence accelerated by a velocity-space spectral approach in the full-f GK code GENE-X. Building upon the original grid velocity-space discretization, we derive and implement a new spectral formulation and verify the numerical implementation using the method of manufactured solution. We conduct a series of spectral turbulence simulations focusing on the TCV-X21 reference case (Oliveira et al., 2022 [26]) and compare these results with previously validated grid simulations (Ulbl et al., 2023 [25]). The spectral approach reproduces the outboard midplane (OMP) profiles (density, temperature, and radial electric field), dominated by trapped electron mode (TEM) turbulence, with excellent agreement and significantly lower velocity-space resolution. As a consequence, the spectral approach reduces the computational cost (CPUh) by at least an order of magnitude, of approximately 50 for the TCV-X21 case. This enables high-fidelity GK simulations to be performed within a few days on modern CPU-based supercomputers for medium-sized devices and establishes GENE-X as a powerful tool for studying edge and SOL turbulence, moving towards reactor-relevant devices like ITER.

Gyrokinetic↗
DOE OSTI2023

Reinforcement learning for real-time process control in high-temperature superconductor manufacturing

With high efficiency and low energy loss, high-temperature superconductors (HTS) have demonstrated their profound applications in various fields, such as medical imaging, transportation, accelerators, microwave devices, and power systems. The high-field applications of HTS tapes have raised the demand for producing cost-effective tapes with long lengths in superconductor manufacturing. However, achieving the uniform and enhanced performance of a long HTS tape is challenging due to the unstable growth conditions in the manufacturing process. Although it is confirmed that the process parameters during the advanced metal organic chemical vapor deposition (A-MOCVD) process influence the uniformity of the produced HTS tapes, the high-dimensional process parameter signals and their complicated interactions make it difficult to develop an effective control policy. In this paper, we propose a local measure for the uniformity of HTS tapes to provide instant feedback for our control policy. Then, we model the manufacturing of HTS tapes as a Markov decision process (MDP) with continuous state and action spaces to assess the instant reward in real time in our feedback control model. As our MDP involves continuous and high-dimensional state and action spaces, a neural fitted Q-iteration (NFQ) algorithm is adopted to solve the MDP with artificial neural network (ANN) function approximation. The collinearity of process parameters can restrict our capability of adjusting the process parameters, which is addressed by the principal component analysis (PCA) in our method. The control policy adjusts the PCA of process parameters using the NFQ algorithm. In conclusion, based on our case studies on real A-MOCVD dataset, the obtained control policy increases the average uniformity of tapes by 5.6% and performs especially well on sample HTS tapes with a low uniformity.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2023

10. Path Modifiers

Toolpaths for additive manufacturing are typically broken into three types: closed-loop, open-loop, and space-filling. Each of these toolpaths serve a specific purpose and are often used in combination to construct an object. The standard implementation of each toolpath commands a constant motion speed and extrusion rate throughout the length of the path. The 3D printer will then make any necessary adjustments during interpolation of the motion, such as accelerating and decelerating when traversing a corner. However, sometimes more finite control and additional pathing can be needed to ensure the successful printing of a path. This chapter will outline path modifiers and how they can be used to enhance the printability of a toolpath by modifying parameters or adding segments.

Roschli, Alex↗
DOE OSTI2020

Initial Temperature Testing of Advanced Manufactured Melt Wire Package

As a part of the In-Pile Instrumentation Program, The Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has recently established in-house capabilities to fabricate and test new advanced manufactured sensors for measuring the peak irradiation temperature inside a nuclear test reactor. Although nuclear test reactors can use standard methods of real-time temperature monitoring, such as thermocouples, the complexity of feedthroughs and attachment complications to collect real-time measurements greatly increases the cost of the experiment. Passive monitoring techniques may be utilized that exploit the melting point of well characterized material (standard melt wires), however, the limited space available for instrumentation during experiments is also a challenge. To accommodate the challenge, INL has expanded its temperature detection instrumentation capabilities paired with the advancement of in-house advanced manufacturing options to include printed melt wires for peak irradiation temperature measurement. The advanced manufactured melt wire package can determine peak temperatures in experiments that can fit the challenging space available during irradiation. Recent results and knowledge from this ongoing work have made it possible to develop unique temperature sensors that can accomplish user specific temperature ranges inside the harsh environments experienced during radiation testing. This report summarizes the initial temperature testing using fabricated melt wires with two different melting temperatures, silver (melting temperature of ~960 °C) and solder (melting temperature of ~160 °C), that were initially tested for their relative melting points using non-standard method of furnace and hot plate testing under normal air conditions. Future work will include more controlled way of testing printed melt wires under inert gas with multiple temperature measurements followed by comparison of standard melt wire package performance for baseline characterization.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗