Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “ABLATING MATERIAL”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

High Energy Density Physics of Inertial Confinement Fusion Ablator Materials

The historic December 5, 2022 experiment at Lawrence Livermore National Lab’s (LLNL) National Ignition Facility (NIF) reached fusion energy ignition for the first time. This is the most important scientific breakthrough of the 21st century paves the way to future clean inertial fusion energy (IFE). The diamond (high density carbon (HDC)) ablator material used in this experiment displays detrimental effects due to the development of hydrodynamic instabilities at the diamond/fuel interface under shock compression. New alternatives to diamond ablators are required to step up the energy yield in ICF experiments. The unique combination of mechanical strength (approaching that of diamond), the ability to accommodate high-Z dopants (in contrast to diamond), and the tunability of the properties (through synthesis material with varying sp 3 content) make amorphous carbon (a-C) a promising material for next-generation IFE ablative capsules. However, despite its critical importance to the IFE program, the behavior of a-C carbon at extreme temperatures and pressures remains largely unexplored. The primary goals of this project were to perform groundbreaking dynamic compression experiments and predictive simulations to uncover the fundamental high-energy-density physics of amorphous carbon. Our goals were (1) to uncover the metastability range of amorphous carbon and probe phase transitions to diamond or metastable supercooled liquid carbon; (2) to acquire high-quality equation of state (EOS) data and develop an experimentally validated EOS from machine-learning MD simulations of the complex states of carbon; and (3) to uncover the complex behavior of carbon liquid in both thermodynamically stable and metastable supercooled states by accessing large areas of carbon phase diagram with amorphous samples with variable sp 3 content. Our proposed experimental program included measurements of equation of state and diffraction measurements using the Omega EP laser at the Laboratory of Laser Energetics at the University of Rochester. The theoretical/simulation program involved the development of machine-learning models of the complex response of amorphous carbon under dynamic compression by performing molecular dynamics simulations at experimental time and length scales using leadership class DOE supercomputers. Simulations guided experiments to observe predicted phenomena and acquire critical experimental data in specific pressure-temperature domains to validate theoretical models. This research delivered fundamental properties of novel amorphous carbon IFE ablator material, including phase diagram and EOS. These results will aid in IFE target design and implosion experiments. A unique combination of predictive simulations and dynamic and static experiments provided a highly inspirational intellectual environment for graduate students and postdocs involved in this project.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

High Energy Density Physics of Inertial Confinement Fusion Ablator Materials (Final Technical Report)

The goal of this project was to conduct dynamic compression experiments and predictive simulations to reveal the fundamental high-energy-density (HED) physics of amorphous carbon. These results are essential for assessing amorphous carbon as a potential ablator material for next generation of inertial confinement fusion (ICF) capsules. We made significant progress in exploring the HED properties of amorphous carbon through experiments at Omega EP Laser and the European XFEL, in addition to billion-atom, quantum-accurate molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Through our joint experimental and simulation program, we mapped the phase diagram of amorphous carbon, uncovering its range of metastability and identifying phase transitions to diamond and liquid carbon along the Hugoniot and at higher pressures using double shock compression pathways. Our findings indicate that amorphous carbon melts at significantly lower shock pressures than high-density carbon (diamond). However, nanocrystalline diamond nucleates across a broad range of pressures and temperatures. This emergence of the nanocrystalline microstructure during compression can negatively impact the planarity of the shock front and potentially trigger ablator/fuel mixing during Inertial Fusion Energy (IFE) applications.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Characterization of ablator dynamics initiated by picket-pulse conditions

Direct-drive laser-fusion targets may include low-cost plastic ablator material. Here, this work describes a tabletop experimental system designed to enable the investigation of the interaction of such ablator material as a function of the laser wavelength and the associated excitation mechanism. This experimental system offers time-resolved imaging of the material response with subpicosecond temporal resolution and ≈1-μm spatial resolution. The system involves synchronized femtosecond and picosecond lasers to initiate and characterize the dynamics of polystyrene planar targets irradiated by conditions similar to a “picket” prepulse from a direct-drive pulse shape. Ultrafast imaging of the initial excitation process followed by the resulting critical plasma formation, shock-wave propagation, and blowoff plasma expansion is used to compare the impact of excitation wavelength, 355 nm or 266 nm, on the ensuing dynamics. This work aims to investigate fundamental laser material interactions to help advance physics models that can inform the development of laser driver and target designs.

42 ENGINEERING

High-Power Impulse Magnetron Sputter Deposition of Boron Carbide with Full-Face Erosion Magnetron and Mixed Ar-Ne Plasma

Boron carbide (B 4 C) is an attractive inertial confinement fusion ablator material. The fabrication of B4C ablators by magnetron sputtering requires process optimization. To increase process flexibility, here we explore high-power impulse magnetron sputter (HiPIMS) deposition of B 4 C in pure Ar and mixed Ar-Ne plasmas. Here, the results show that higher plasma discharge currents can be reached with a mixed Ar-Ne plasma in the entire working pressure range studied (5 𝑡𝑜 50 mTorr). At 45 mTorr with 10% of Ne in the Ar-Ne mix, high peak target current densities of ~1 A cm −2 were demonstrated. Films deposited with such a mixed Ar-Ne plasma with a full-face erosion magnetron source on substrates biased at −25 V exhibited higher density and improved mechanical properties, albeit with higher compressive residual stresses compared to the case of HiPIMS deposition in a pure Ar plasma. This work demonstrates additional process flexibility of the HiPIMS discharge mode for the deposition of B 4 C coatings.

Ablator capsule

High-Rate Sputter Deposition of Ultrathick Boron Carbide Coatings on Rolling Spherical Substrates

Amorphous boron carbide (B 4 C) is a promising next-generation ablator material for inertial confinement fusion. However, the deposition of ultrathick B4C coatings with submicron-scale density uniformity on spherical substrates, as required for ablator shell fabrication, remains challenging. Here, in this study, we use direct current magnetron sputtering to deposit B 4 C onto 2-mm-diameter Si spheres rolling in a dish-shaped substrate holder. High deposition rates of ∼3 μm/h are achieved. Ultrathick films have a columnar microstructure, with the column width determined by the density of nodular defects. Nodular defect nucleation is dominated by the pickup of particulates from the holder during substrate rolling. We demonstrate the fabrication of a hollow B 4 C spherical shell with a wall thickness of 80 μm. Also demonstrated is the laser machining of holes in the B 4 C coating, which is necessary for both the chemical removal of the Si template and the attachment of a fusion fuel fill tube.

Inertial confinement fusion targets

Single-shot in-line x-ray phase-contrast imaging of void-shockwave interactions in fusion energy materials

Recent breakthroughs in nuclear fusion, specifically the report of reactions exceeding scientific breakeven at the National Ignition Facility (NIF), highlight the potential of inertial fusion energy (IFE) as a sustainable and virtually limitless energy source. However, further progress in IFE requires characterization of defects in ablator materials and how they affect fuel capsule compression. Voids within the ablator can degrade energy yield, but their impact on the density distribution has primarily been studied through simulations, with limited high-resolution experimental validation. To address this, we used the x-ray free-electron laser (XFEL) at the matter in extreme conditions (MECs) instrument at the Linac coherent light source (LCLS) to capture 2D x-ray phase-contrast (XPC) images of a void-bearing sample with a composition similar to inertial confinement fusion (ICF) ablators. By driving a compressive shockwave through the sample using MEC's long-pulse laser system, we analyzed how voids influence shockwave propagation and density distribution during compression. To quantify this impact, we extracted phase information using two phase retrieval algorithms. First, we applied the contrast transfer function (CTF) method, paired with Tikhonov regularization and a fast optimization approach to generate an initial phase estimate. We then refined the result using a projected gradient descent (PGD) method that works directly with the sample's refractive index. Comparing these results with radiation adaptive grid Eulerian (xRAGE) radiation hydrodynamic simulations enables identification of model validation needs or improvements. By calculating phase maps in situ, it becomes possible to reconstruct areal density maps, improving understanding of laser-capsule interactions and advancing IFE research.

Hodge, D. S. [Colorado State Univ., Fort Collins,

Demonstration of a Novel Radiochemical Mix Diagnostic for Fusion Implosions at the National Ignition Facility

Mixing of the ablator material into the fuel of an inertial confinement fusion implosion reduces compression and enhances radiative losses, preventing ignition. Here, we describe a novel use of charged-particle radiochemistry to measure the ablator mix in contact with the fusion hot spot. The capsule uses a graded Be-Cr layer to increase the confinement of the hot spot. 52 Mn and 51 Cr isotopes are collected from the implosion and counted, and the ratio is related to the amount of Cr mixed into the hot spot. Thus, a new diagnostic to determine the degradation due to mix on fusion implosions has been developed.

MacLaren, S. A. [Lawrence Livermore National Labor

Microphysics of shock-grain interaction for inertial confinement fusion ablators in a fluid approach

Ablator materials used for inertial confinement fusion, such as high-density carbon (HDC) and beryllium, have grain structure which may lead to small-scale density nonuniformity and the generation of perturbations when the materials are shocked and compressed. Here, we use a combination of a linear theory of shock interaction with density nonuniformity [Velikovich et al., Phys. Plasmas 14, 072706 (2007)] and numerical simulations to study shock interaction with a model representation of HDC grains. While the shock-grain interaction is nonlinear, the linear theory shows some key features of the shock-grain interaction, which also hold for the (nonlinear) simulations. The postshock perturbations are made up of sonic reflections off of grain boundaries and vorticity deposition along them, with the latter dominating the perturbed energy content. The mean (per mass) postshock perturbed kinetic energy decreases with increasing grain size, but energy will be deposited at increasing spatial scale. From the perspective of the postshock perturbed energy, the detailed linear theory largely supports a proposed method [S. Davidovits et al., Phys. Plasmas 29, 112708 (2022)] for deresolving the grains (in a similar grains model) that treats the grains statistically. Finally, our simulation results highlight the influence of thermal conduction on the perturbation dynamics at grain scales.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Improving indirect-drive ablator performance through pulse shaping and material selection in double shell implosions

The double shell path to inertially confined volumetric thermonuclear burn relies on efficient kinetic energy transfer from an outer ablator shell to an inner shell containing DT fuel at implosion velocities near 250 km/s. In order to experimentally realize adequate compression, target imperfections and assembly features must be tightly controlled. Pulse shape and ablator material are critical design choices that impact all aspects of the implosion. In this article, we evaluate three designs: an Al ablator with single-shock radiation drive, a CH ablator with single-shock drive, and a CH ablator with reduced-adiabat 2-shock drive. All designs use the same W inner (pusher) shell overcoated with a glow discharge polymer tamper and filled with liquid-density DT. One-dimensional HYDRA simulations revealed that the plastic ablator design required the use of the 2-shock drive to match the performance of the Al design. Two-dimensional simulations resolving broadband surface roughness up to modes of several hundred placed only on the ablator showed plastic to greatly outperform Al. The plastic ablator designs did exhibit higher levels of inner shell instability growth when surface roughness was only placed at the pusher/tamper interface, which was mitigated with higher foam cushion densities. A unique and additional benefit of a plastic ablator is also discussed, where heating of the ablator by Au M-band radiation is predicted to rapidly expand the hemi-shell surfaces, closing the equatorial joint gap ahead of the first shock. Taken together, the properties of the plastic ablator for indirect-drive double shell implosions appear promising in removing several long-standing fabrication challenges.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Sample glue layer investigation and mitigation for laser induced prompt impulse experiments

Understanding longer timescale material reactions under dynamic stress loading is critical for applications in materials engineering, shock physics, and planetary science. Prompt impulse experiments generate lower pressures since the ablator—the material first removed by the laser—is thicker and farther from the diagnostic plane, capturing aggregate material responses from the initial shock wave, rarefaction waves, and later time effects. This complexity demands thorough material characterization and simulation support. Since traditional sample construction is specific to supported shock experiments, designing prompt impulse experiments requires reconsideration around target design and sample engineering. Here, we present sample preparation techniques, experimental investigations, and theoretical simulations to investigate glue layer impacts, aiming to standardize samples for consistent data at lower laser fluences. We find that glue layers <30 μm have a minimal impact on peak velocity and pulse shape. The peak velocity scales linearly with glue layer thickness until a glue layer of 75 μm. For glue layers >75 μm, the peak velocity no longer scales with thickness; however, the pulse shape continues to degrade as described by simulations.

Lasers

Calibration-free analysis of Li isotope ratios using laser ablation and laser absorption spectroscopy

We introduce a rapid, calibration-free, all-optical method for high-precision lithium isotope ratio measurements in solid materials using laser ablation combined with tunable laser absorption spectroscopy. A new asynchronous acquisition method is used to acquire time-resolved, high-resolution spectra of the 6Li and 7Li D1 and D2 transitions near 671 nm. Isotope ratios and atomic column densities are extracted from measured spectra via a physics-based fitting model including hyperfine structure. Under 1 Torr air, spectra recorded = 0.75 ms after plasma onset exhibit narrow linewidths corresponding to Doppler temperatures = 400 K, enabling resolution of the isotope peaks with high signal-to-noise ratios. Analysis of LiAlO2 samples with varying 6Li:7Li ratios demonstrates isotopic precisions of 0.6–1.7% for spectra acquired in 30 s. Isotope ratios determined from the spectral fits show accuracy within –0.3% to –1.7% of reference ICP-MS measurements without requiring calibration to external standards. By eliminating sample preparation and enabling spatially resolved isotopic mapping, this method offers a rapid analysis approach to lithium isotope determination in solid materials relevant to nuclear energy, safeguards, and geochemistry.

Phillips, Mark C.

Towards Portable Laser Desorption Postionization Mass Spectrometry Utilizing Microchip Laser Pulses

A 355 nm, 1.5 ns, up to 1 kHz microchip laser system has been tested to both yield ablation spots and postionize material within a plasma plume. A 30 µJ pulse energy microchip laser successfully ablated all samples: 6601 aluminum, 316 and 304 stainless steel, and Mo metal. While visible ablation craters were observed on all samples mentioned above, the stainless-steel samples displayed visible color changes in the resolidified iron, indicating ionization with the 355 nm pulses during ablation. Additionally, when used to intercept a plasma plume of Cs 2 CO 3 made with a separate laser system, the microchip laser pulses yielded Cs + emission signal otherwise not observed. With these experiments completed, the microchip laser has been successfully verified for readiness to be integrated into the front end of a mass spectrometer system as the ion source.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Wetted-foam target stability for laser-direct-drive inertial confinement fusion

Using highly resolved three-dimensional radiation-hydrodynamic simulations, the effects of wetted-foam (WF) ablators in direct-drive inertial confinement fusion cryogenic implosions on the OMEGA laser were investigated. The performance of these implosions was compared with that of implosions using targets with solid-plastic ablators. Simulations considering WF ablators as a homogeneous material show no mitigation of the effects of laser imprint, where the absence of this mitigation can be attributed to the use of picket pulses. Heterogeneous random-structure WF ablators introduce large short-wavelength perturbations, which are seeded by WF inhomogeneities. These perturbations exceed the perturbations seeded by the imprint and cause an additional reduction in implosion performance when the average pore size in the WF exceeds ~0.2 μm. Foam-seeded perturbations are expected to be less damaging in more stable high-adiabat (⁠ ≳ 5⁠) implosions. Here, the perturbations introduced by the WF ablators can be substantially reduced by using a foam matrix with a layered structure instead of a random one. Further study of the effects of WFs in ignition designs of the MJ laser energy scale is required in the perspective of future inertial fusion energy mass production.

Igumenshchev, I. V. [University of Rochester, NY (

Numerical investigation of liquid wall ablation in inertial fusion energy chambers

This paper presents a novel approach for modeling liquid wall ablation in liquid wall-protected inertial fusion energy (IFE) chambers. These systems are promising candidates for the implementation of fusion technology, yet significant gaps remain in understanding the underlying physical processes and their implications for design. Following target ignition, a portion of the fusion energy is released as x-rays, which deposit their energy into an array of liquid jets, leading to partial vaporization. Accurately modeling this heat deposition and vaporization process remains challenging due to the complex geometries typical of (pre-conceptual) IFE chamber designs. Furthermore, the subsequent expansion of vaporized material into the chamber’s vacuum environment poses difficulties for conventional CFD methods based on continuum assumptions, which can lead to significant inaccuracies. To address some aspects of these challenges, this work introduces a ray-tracing-based methodology to map the spatial distribution of ablated material in liquid wall-protected systems. In addition, a vacuum-tracking scheme is developed to extend the applicability of an OpenFOAM-based solver to gas dynamics in rarefied environments. The proposed approach has been verified through numerical benchmarks and applied to a practical case involving the HYLIFE-II (High Yield Lithium Injection Fusion Energy) chamber. The methodology advances the modeling capabilities for liquid wall-protected IFE systems and provides valuable tools to support their design and optimization.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Femto-second Laser’s Enabling New Length Scale Fabrications for Rapid Post Irradiation Examination of Materials: Concluding LDRD Project Poster

Mechanical testing campaigns are required to qualify materials for advanced reactor conditions, yet economical and safety limitations restrict the number of standardized mechanical tests that can be performed. Reducing the size of the sample is one approach to addressing these challenges and to accelerating testing. Previous research has shown that smaller mechanical test samples produce higher yield and ultimate stress values compared to values measured from standard sample sizes: the “smaller is stronger” effect. Specimens used in accelerated material testing campaigns must reflect bulk material performance to enable engineering scale material property measurement. The objective of this research project was to determine if engineering scale mechanical behavior—the yield stress—could be measured with micro-tensile test samples smaller than traditional standard testing geometries. The relationship between yield stress and sample size was explored with two different nuclear-relevant structural materials: Zircaloy-4 and tungsten. Mechanical testing of both metals demonstrated decreasing yield stress values with increasing sample gauge size across three different sizes. Yield stress values from the largest gauge size, fabricated with a femto-second laser ablation system, approach bulk material yield stress values reported in published literature. Preliminary analysis of the tungsten samples indicates the yield stress value depends on the grain characteristics within the gauge section, in addition to the gauge size. Accompanying modeling efforts, including response surface generation and crystal plasticity approaches, further demonstrated that the size of the sample gauge section alone cannot explain the change in yield stress values.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE