Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “counter electrode”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Implementing hydrogen oxidation reaction on Pt for controlling counter electrode processes

The search for active, stable, and durable materials for electrochemical energy technologies requires increasing levels of precision to establish true structure-function relationships and guide materials design from atomic and molecular scale. This increases the level of control required over the experimental system for proper materials evaluation. The choice of counter electrode material become crucial, as Pt dissolution at high voltages may cause contamination to the working electrode, especially when studying reductive processes in reactions such as oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), H 2 evolution reaction (HER), and the CO 2 reduction reaction. The learnings from “old school” electrochemistry groups lead us to leverage H 2 reactions over Pt to construct a counter electrode system with controlled potential that eliminates Pt ion contamination concerns. In here we discuss the construction of such Pt|H 2 counter electrode where key experimental aspects such as the H 2 flow rate and effective distribution determines the maximum current this counter electrode can accommodate before switching to high voltage and triggering Pt dissolution. Lastly, we demonstrate the use of the Pt|H 2 counter electrode in aqueous electrolytes during HER occurring on the working electrode at varying currents, showing that the Pt content in the cell remains below parts per trillion (ppt) up to 10 mA, and below 50 ppt at 100 mA up to 1 h of constant current hold. This work provides a guide to the implementation of Pt|H 2 counter electrodes to improve the precision of electrochemical experiments in search of highly active, selective, and durable materials for energy technologies.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Is Pt dissolution a concern from the counter electrode in electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction?

The Pt metal and its oxides dissolution from the counter electrode (CE, in hydrogen evolution reaction (HER)) has been suspected to affect the non-noble metal catalysts toward oxygen evolution reaction (OER). However, little effort has been devoted to this concern, and this work aims to determine the effect. The influence of electrolytes (H 2 SO 4 and NaOH) and Pt CE (acid-treated and pristine) on the Pt dissolution and membrane separations (Nafion and PiperION) on preventing Pt species migration were evaluated. Here, the results indicate only 11.2 ppb Pt from the cathodic electrolyte with Nafion 211 and 5 M NaOH electrolyte is observed, and no Pt is found from all other samples with acid-treated Pt CE. Regarding pristine Pt CE, 0.4 and 4.4 ppb Pt are observed from 0.5 M H 2 SO 4 and 5 M NaOH electrolytes, respectively. The findings in this work include: (1) Nafion membrane can effectively prevent the migration of Pt species from the cathode to the anode side; (2) a simple acid treatment of Pt could minimize the Pt dissolution into the acid electrolyte while showing an opposite role in the alkaline electrolyte; (3) the Pt dissolution from all experiments is minor, indicating Pt is a suitable CE for OER.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Enhanced performance of Bi 2 S 3 /TiO 2 heterostructure composite films for solar cell applications

Day to day energy production is shifting towards renewable energy sources as these sources become more economically viable while being less polluting to operate; solar energy has become one of the major sources of renewable energy. However, it currently relies on ultra-pure silicon ingots to produce commercial silicon photovoltaics, which prevents the cost of electricity being produced to compete with non-renewable energy production. A viable low-cost alternative for silicon based cells would be dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs), which are easier and cheaper to manufacture as they do not require expensive and delicate raw materials to make. Moreover, they could be made semi-flexible which allows for a greater variety of applications. A DSSC consists of three components, a photo-electrode, an electrolyte and a counter-electrode. When exposed to incident light, the complex photosensitizers in the photoelectrode release electrons which are transported to the external load, leaving the photoelectrode in an oxidized state. The electrons are collected by the counter electrode and used to reduce the electrolyte. This charged electrolyte then reduces the positively charged photoelectrode, allowing the process to begin again. To improve the efficiency of this process, we explore the use of bismuth sulfide (Bi 2 S 3 ) and titanium oxide (TiO 2 ) composite as photoelectrode material and investigate their impact on the efficiency of DSSC.

14 SOLAR ENERGY

Electrochemical stability and corrosion behavior of Ni-Cr alloy in molten LiCl-KCl salt

This study investigated the electrochemical properties and potential-dependent stability of Cr(II) and Ni(II) in a eutectic LiCl-KCl molten salt at 500 °C under an argon atmosphere using a three-electrode cell configuration with a glassy carbon working electrode, Ag/Ag + reference electrode, and graphite counter electrode. Cyclic voltammetry was employed to characterize the Cr(0)/Cr(II)/Cr(III) and Ni(0)/Ni(II) redox transitions, yielding diffusion coefficients of 0.50 (±0.01) × 10 −5 cm 2 s −1 for Cr(II) and 0.91 (±0.16) × 10 −5 cm 2 s −1 for Ni(II) at 500 °C. The redox stability domains of these species provided insight into the corrosion mechanisms of a Ni-Cr alloy (80–20 wt %) in LiCl-KCl salt. The measured open circuit potential of the alloy corresponded to the range of potentials where the Ni(0) and Cr(II) species are stable, indicating a preferential dissolution of Cr. Immersion testing of the alloy for 336 h confirmed significant Cr depletion (or Ni-enrichment) at the surface layer, corroborating Cr dealloying as the dominant corrosion reaction under open circuit conditions. Additionally, the application of a small anodic overpotential (0.11 V) resulted in selective Cr dissolution while a large anodic overpotential (0.25 V) resulted in co-dissolution of both Cr and Ni. Furthermore, these results demonstrate that the corrosion mechanisms of a Ni-Cr alloy in LiCl-KCl depend upon the applied potential, and thus the redox conditions of the molten salt should be carefully controlled in the design of a redox buffer to mitigate corrosion in molten salt environments.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS

Precious metal oxygen-evolving anodes for electrolytic reduction of metal oxides in molten LiCl-Li 2 O electrolyte

Understanding the electrochemical stability of oxygen-evolving anode materials in molten salt electrolytes is essential to enable decarbonized electrolytic reduction of metal oxides (e.g., used nuclear oxide fuels). Here, this work investigated three precious metals (Ir, Ru, and Pt) as oxygen-evolving anodes in molten LiCl-Li 2 O (99.0-1.0 wt%) at 650 °C. For consistent measurements, this work employed a three-electrode cell comprised of a two-phase Li-Bi (65-35 at%) reference electrode and a NiO counter electrode. Anodic polarization behavior of each anode was investigated via cyclic voltammetry (CV) and chronoamperometry. The onset potential for oxygen evolution was observed at E > 2.9 V (vs. Li/Li + ) for the Ir and Ru anodes and anodic current density was as high as 1.0 A cm -2 at 3.23 V. The dimensional stability of each anode was evaluated from long-term electrolysis experiments (10.0-32.1 h) at 3.23 V. Rapid consumption of the Pt anode was observed after the application of 26,453 C cm -2 with a reduction in diameter of about 15.8% due to the formation of a non-protective Li 2 PtO 3 compound. The formation of this compound was also observed during CV measurements as additional anodic waves at potentials more negative than that of oxygen evolution. In contrast, both the Ir and Ru anodes exhibited excellent dimensional stability with a reduction in diameter or thickness of less than 1.5% even after applying greater charge density of ~41,100 C cm -2 , demonstrating superior stability during oxygen evolution in the LiCl-Li 2 O electrolyte.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Electrochemical Recovery of Rare-Earth Elements from Coal Fly Ash Using Ionic Liquids as both Extractant and Electrolyte

Rare-earth elements (REEs) are critical for medical technologies, electronics, and clean energy. Coal fly ash (CFA), a byproduct of coal combustion, offers a promising alternative REE source. However, efficient extraction and separation of REEs from CFA remain challenging due to the complex composition of CFA. This study introduces a sustainable method for REE recovery using a recyclable ionic liquid, betainium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([Hbet]- [Tf 2 N]), which serves both as the extractant from CFA and as the electrolyte in electrodeposition. In the first stage, [Hbet][Tf 2 N] preferentially extracts REEs from CFA through leaching. In the second stage, the REE-enriched ionic liquid undergoes electrochemical deposition using amperometry techniques, where REEs are reduced and deposited onto the electrode. The deposition experiments were conducted from −0.5 to −2.0 V vs a Pt quasireference electrode in a three-electrode setup comprising titanium as the working electrode and platinum as both the reference and counter electrodes. Varying the applied potential enabled potential-dependent preferential REE deposition. At −0.5 V, neodymium (Nd) showed preferential recovery, reaching 25% with a separation factor of 37 over other REEs. In contrast, applying a more negative potential increased overall deposition, yielding ∼50% Nd recovery and 10−20% recovery for the remaining REEs. After recovery, the ionic liquid was regenerated and reused for a subsequent electrochemical recovery cycle. Overall, this study demonstrates a feasible approach for REE recovery from CFA waste, with potential to enhance resource utilization within the REE supply chain.

coal fly ash

Nucleation-promoting and growth-limiting synthesis of disordered rock-salt Li-ion cathode materials

Disordered rock-salt oxides and oxyfluorides are promising positive electrode materials for high-performance lithium-ion batteries free of nickel and cobalt. However, conventional synthesis methods rely on post-synthesis pulverization to achieve cycling-appropriate particle sizes, offering limited control over particle microstructure and crystallinity. This accelerates degradation and complicates secondary particle processing. Here we present a synthesis strategy that enhances nucleation while suppressing particle growth and agglomeration across various disordered rock-salt compositions, including lithium–manganese–titanium oxide, lithium–manganese–niobium oxide, and lithium–nickel–titanium oxide systems. Applied to Li 1.2 Mn 0.4 Ti 0.4 O 2 , this method yields highly crystalline, well-dispersed sub-200 nm particles that form homogeneous electrode films with stable cycling behavior. Tested in cells with lithium metal as the counter electrode, these electrodes deliver ~200 mAh/g with 85% capacity retention relative to the first cycle after 100 cycles (20 mA/g, 1.5–4.8 V), and an average discharge voltage loss of 4.8 mV per cycle, compared to 38.6% retention and 7.5 mV loss per cycle for electrodes derived from pulverized solid-state particles. This approach suggests a route to enhance the performance and durability of disordered rock-salt electrodes for sustainable lithium-ion batteries.

Batteries

Linking Pressure to Electrochemical Evolution in Solid-State Conversion Cathode Composites

Conversion-type cathodes, such as sulfur, FeS 2 , and FeF 3 , offer high theoretical capacities in solid-state lithium batteries but are hindered by substantial volume changes during cycling, leading to interfacial contact loss, crack formation, and microstructural degradation. Here, we investigate the relationships between electrochemical, mechanical, and structural evolution in solid-state electrode composites with these three active materials. Using real-time stack-pressure monitoring, synchrotron X-ray absorption spectroscopy, and electrokinetic modeling, we elucidate how stress evolution is linked to reversible and irreversible redox reactions. Nonlinear stack pressure evolution in cells with sulfur, FeS 2 , and FeF 3 electrode composites is found to arise from material-specific volume changes, the balance of volume change between the working and counter electrode, and the formation of distinct reaction intermediates. The three materials exhibit distinct stack pressure evolution, which is closely related to the different reaction processes in the materials, as demonstrated with X-ray absorption spectroscopy measurements. Through mesoscale modeling, we relate the experimental measurements to species evolution at the particle scale and track the dynamic coexistence of intermediate phases. Our findings highlight the importance of designing for volume changes of a given active material in solid-state battery systems.

batteries

Ca Metal Batteries and Sn Anode Alloying: Resolving Misconceptions in Ca–Sn Alloy Formation

Ca metal anode suffers from surface passivation and struggles to effectively plate and strip in conventional Ca electrolytes, making the development of alloy anode for calcium metal battery essential. This work systematically and carefully evaluates the electrochemical formation and feasibility of the Sn anode and its possibility of alloying with Ca using a combination of cyclic voltammetry, scanning electron microscopy with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM/EDS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), and synchrotron transmission X-ray microscopy (TXM). Electrochemical measurements and SEM/EDS analyses indicate apparent Ca alloy formation. However, detailed XRD and TXM characterization reveal substantial lithium-ion involvement when lithium metal is employed as the reference electrode, even in electrolytes with high Ca salt concentrations. These findings highlight a significant risk of misinterpretation: Although limited Ca–Sn alloying may occur, the faster kinetics of Li + can dominate the alloying process, leading to a Li-driven reactions at the Sn anode. In contrast, cells constructed with Ca metal as both reference and counter electrodes exhibit distinct redox features only during the initial cycles, followed by rapid cell failure. The high oxidation currents induce severe Ca passivation, occurring nearly concurrently with Sn dealloying. Overall, this study provides critical insight into the practical limitations and common experimental artifacts associated with Ca metal battery systems and underscores the necessity for rigorous cell design and cautious interpretation when evaluating alloy chemistry in multivalent Ca-based batteries.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Investigating the effect of screen-printed structured graphite electrodes with low tortuosity for high-capacity and fast-charging lithium-ion batteries

A flexible screen-printed graphite electrode was fabricated as an anode for developing fast-charging lithium-ion batteries with low tortuosity. A homogenous anode ink was prepared by mixing graphite as the active material, carbon black (C45) as the conductive additive, and polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) as the binder in N-Methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP) solvent. The ink was deposited on a flexible copper foil via a stainless-steel screen consisting of an array of pores, that act as secondary pore networks (SPNs), using the screen-printing process. Lithium-ion battery half-cells were assembled using the printed graphite anode, lithium metal foil as the counter electrode, and 1.2 M lithium hexafluorophosphate (LiPF 6 ) in ethyl carbonate: ethyl methyl carbonate (EC: EMC = 3:7) as the electrolyte. The effect of SPNs on the cell performance was investigated by performing formation, rate and cycling tests on the assembled cells, at different C-rates. It was observed that the cells consisting of SPNs with a pore size of 100 μm and edge-to-edge distance of 100 μm between the pores exhibited significantly higher specific capacities of 168 and 129 mAh/g when compared to reference cells without SPNs, which had capacities of 120 and 85 mAh/g, at high C-rates of 4 C and 6 C, respectively. The cells with SPNs also demonstrated excellent cycling performance with ~ 95% capacity retention after 100 cycles at 2 C.

Fast charging lithium-ion battery

Impact of Anode to Cathode Crossover in Lithium‐metal Batteries With High‐Nickel Cathodes

The advancement of high-energy-density lithium-metal batteries (LMBs) is hindered by the chemical instability of both lithium-metal anode and high-nickel layered oxide cathodes. While cathode-to-anode crossover is well-documented, the reverse process of anode-to-cathode crossover remains underexplored. Here, we systematically investigate such crossovers and the degradation pathway in pouch cells with a localized high-concentration electrolyte, comparing NMC622, NMC811, and NMC90 cathodes paired with lithium-metal and graphite anodes. Despite delivering higher initial capacities, LMBs exhibit faster capacity fade under long-term cycling at 45 °C. To isolate cathode-side degradation, galvanostatic electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (GEIS) measurements of cycled cathodes paired with delithiated lithium iron phosphate (LFP) counter electrodes reveal significantly higher charge-transfer resistance in cathodes cycled with lithium-metal. Surface characterization via X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) reveals greater electrolyte decomposition on cathodes cycled with lithium metal, leading to thicker, more organic-rich cathode–electrolyte interphases (CEIs), consistent with the elevated charge-transfer resistance observed in GEIS measurements. Notably, NMC90 shows the most pronounced CEI thickening, linking higher cathode surface reactivity to greater susceptibility to anode-to-cathode crossover. This work presents compelling evidence of crosstalk degradation originating from lithium-metal anodes and underscores the importance of cross-interface stability for the design of durable LMBs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE

Mechanistic Insights into the Surface Instabilities of TiNb 2 O 7, a High‐Power Li‐Ion Anode

TiNb 2 O 7 (TNO) is a promising Li-ion battery anode for high-power applications, such as implantable medical devices and heavy-duty equipment. Hailed as being safe due to its elevated operating potential near 1.6 V, TNO has long been assumed to be highly stable in the carbonate-based electrolytes used in Li-ion batteries. Herein, all mechanisms occurring at the surface of both TNO and Nd-doped TNO are identified, and both materials in fact show significant gassing. CO 2 is even released at open circuit conditions, demonstrating the poor chemical stability of the material in the electrolyte even prior to battery operation. Such extreme instability is a critical safety concern. In addition, it was found that Ti dissolves from the surface of TNO particles at low voltage (below 1.4 V vs Li), and in fact deposits on the counter electrode. Ti further inside TNO particles then diffuses to the Ti-poor surface during discharge. Partial carbon-coating as a mitigating measure has also been tested and found to exacerbate these processes. The findings identify novel reactions occurring within TNO, and clearly highlight the need to stabilize the surfaces of TNO in order to prevent such aggressive deterioration at the surface of the particles.

25 ENERGY STORAGE

Single Component Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells Enabled by Copper Chemistry: Introduction of the Retro Cell

The possibility of utilizing a single molecule to act as both a chromophore and a redox shuttle in a new configuration of a dye-sensitized solar cell (DSSC) is investigated. This design, termed a retro cell, exploits the copper chromophore, [Cu(dsbtmp) 2 ] + (dsbtmp = bis(2,9-di(sec-butyl)-3,4,7,8- tetramethyl-1,10-phenanthroline), which has been shown to have excited state lifetimes in excess of a microsecond, enabling sensitization of TiO 2 while dissolved in solution. The oxidized chromophore can then diffuse to the counter electrode to be regenerated. This concept simplifies the device components and fabrication and eliminates a charge transfer step compared to that of traditional DSSCs. Initial investigations show the concept is viable; however, the performance is suboptimal. We have found the addition of 4-tertbutylpyridine (TBP) to the electrolyte plays a crucial role in enabling solar energy conversion. Evidence of TBP displacing one of the dsbtmp ligands in the oxidized [Cu(dsbtmp) 2 ] 2+ complex has been presented, which likely plays an important role in reducing recombination and enabling charge collection. The performance-limiting steps and routes to improved performance and viability of a retro cell are further discussed.

14 SOLAR ENERGY

Modulating Mid-Gap Electronic States Through Site-Selective Modification in B-Pbx/B'-CuyV2O5/CdS Heterostructures for Photocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution

We interfaced ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 compounds, with varying stoichiometries of precisely positioned Pb-ions (x) and Cu-ions (y) in interstitial sites along a tunnel-structured ?-V2O5 framework, with cysteine-capped CdS (cysCdS) quantum dots (QDs) to yield heterostructured photocatalysts. ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 compounds exhibit midgap electronic states with orbital contributions from both Cu 3d and stereochemically active Pb 6s states that show distinctive light-initiated reactivity with photoexcited QDs. ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures were prepared by linker-assisted assembly (LAA). Scanning and transmission electron microscopy, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and Raman spectroscopy revealed that cysCdS QDs were deposited onto surfaces of ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 via LAA. HAXPES revealed that the site-selective positioning of Pb-ions and Cu-ions promoted close energetic alignment of the midgap states of ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 compounds with the valence-band maximum of cysCdS QDs. Transient absorption spectroscopy revealed that photogenerated holes were transferred from CdS QDs to midgap states of ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 compounds on time scales <50 ps. Finally, photoelectrochemical and photochemical experiments revealed that ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures promoted the photocatalytic reduction of H+ to H2. In photoelectrochemical experiments, under oxidative conditions, for all ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures, H2 was evolved at a Pt counter electrode while a sacrificial donor was oxidized at the heterostructure-functionalized working electrode. In contrast, under reductive conditions, for ..beta..-Pb0.152V2O5/CdS and ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures, H2 was evolved at the working electrode. In photochemical experiments, dispersed ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures promoted the reduction of H+ to H2 under white-light illumination; ..beta..'-Cu0.55V2O5/CdS and ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5/CdS heterostructures, for which midgap states have Cu 3d orbital character, generated 2-fold more H2 than ..beta..-Pb0.152V2O5/CdS heterostructures. Cu-ion insertion thus appends additional acceptor surface states that improve ligand-mediated hole transfer from photoexcited QDs, but such states are intrinsically limited in mediating hole transport to the substrate as a result of the low mobility of holes in narrow Cu 3d-states. Our results reveal that the density and orbital character of midgap states of ..beta..-Pbx/..beta..'-CuyV2O5 compounds, tunable through recently developed site-selective ion insertion strategies, determine efficiencies of charge-transfer and charge-transport mechanisms that underpin photocatalysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Hydrophobic Carbon Nanosheets as Passivation Layer for Perovskite Solar Cells with High Efficiency and Stability (Final Technical Report)

Hybrid organic-inorganic metal halide perovskites have continually demonstrated competitive advantages for photovoltaic applications due to their high light absorption coefficient, tunable bandgaps, ambipolar charge mobility and high tolerance of defects. However, there are many challenges yet to overcome to bring this technology to the market. For instance, bridging the ‘scaling gap’ and transitioning PSCs from a lab scale to an industrial scale is a serious challenge. This project developed a high stability and inexpensive perovskite solar cell (PSC) by incorporating hydrophobic carbon nanosheets as counter electrodes (CEs). We demonstrated that the hydrogenated carbon nanosheets with tunable hydrophobic properties as CEs can improve life-time stability of PSCs in operating conditions (i.e. humid air) while achieving impressive power conversion efficiency (PCE).

14 SOLAR ENERGY

Interfacial engineering for high performance carbon-based perovskite solar cells

Perovskite solar cells fabricated with carbon-based counter electrodes demonstrate decreased cost, enhanced simplicity and speed of production, and increased stability compared to those produced with standard metallic electrodes. This significant improvement of device stability, cost reduction, and production scalability indicates a promising direction for commercial development and availability of perovskite solar technology. The main limitation of carbon-based perovskite devices is the flawed contact between the carbon electrode and perovskite film which decreases device quality and performance, thereby necessitating treatment of the carbon/perovskite interface. This review provides an overview of the current state of carbon-based perovskite devices, discusses progress in carbon/perovskite interface modification methods, and suggests future directions for the research of carbon electrode/perovskite film interface manipulation.

14 SOLAR ENERGY

In Situ Liquid Electron Microscope Cells Strongly Attenuate Electrochemical Behavior

In situ electrochemical Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (ec-S/TEM) probes the dynamics of electrochemical processes in real time and at high spatial resolution. This method utilizes microfabricated electrochemical cells, with enclosed dimensions of 800 μm wide, 800 μm long, and 1–2 μm tall, with electron-transparent silicon nitride windows. Working, counter, and reference electrodes in the configuration studied are deposited Pt with a planar surface area of about 1 μm 2 and a height of 50 nm. The cell confines the electrolyte within a 1 μm tall channel, and the microfabricated electrodes have a non-standard geometry, are coplanar, and are not front-facing. As such, standard assumptions of electrochemical experiments do not apply. COMSOL modeling was used to compare and contrast differences in electrochemical behavior between conventional experimental setups and the in situ ec-S/TEM cells. Cell height strongly affected voltammogram measurements: peak magnitudes and shifts correlate directly to cell height. Reactant concentration above the electrode quickly decreases during deposition, leading to a planar diffusion-dominated regime. The concentration gradient prioritizes particle growth along the thin edges of the electrode and not on the planar part of the electrode. Experiments done in the ec-S/TEM ex situ of a TEM verify the model’s accuracy.

Wittman, Reed M. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (O