SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Thermophysical Property Characterization of Irradiated TRISO Compacts to include motivation, experiment background, TCM Experimental Method, TCM Results, Summary, and future work.
Thermophysical Property Characterization of Irradiated TRISO Compacts to include motivation, experiment background, TCM Experimental Method, TCM Results, Summary, and future work.
This study presents a comprehensive analysis of irradiated TRISO fuel particles from the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) Fuel Development and Qualification Program conducted at the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) as part of my internship. Failure Analysis using high-resolution microscopy was performed to characterize mechanisms in TRISO particle layers, including the kernel, buffer, inner pyrolytic carbon (IPyC), silicon carbide (SiC), and outer pyrolytic carbon (OPyC) coatings. Failure modes were systematically classified. Thermal conductivity properties of each TRISO layer were evaluated through experimental measurements and computational models for use in BISON finite element code. Experimental thermal conductivity values ranged from 0.5 W/m·K for the buffer layer to 168 W/m·K for SiC, while BISON simulations provided averaged values of 0.57 W/m·K (buffer), 4.0 W/m·K (PyC layers), and 15.95 W/m·K (SiC). Temperature-dependent correlations from PARFUME were implemented for kernel thermal properties.
The transmission electron microscopic (TEM) examination of an irradiated tristructural isotropic (TRISO) coated particle from advanced gas reactor (AGR) 2 fuel Compact 2-2-2 is presented in this report. Compact 2-2-2 refers to the compact in Capsule 2 at Level 2 of Stack 2. The examination on AGR2 222 RS019 is focused on the interface between the silicon carbide (SiC) to inner pyrolytic carbon (IPyC) layer, central part of SiC, and the interface between SiC and outer pyrolytic carbon layer. The SiC grain boundary distribution and associated fission product precipitates were characterized by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS), and precession electron diffraction (PED) in the transmission electron microscope. Two separate locations on SiC layer were selected for on the basis of the intact of the buffer layer in the irradiated TRISO particle. The key observation in this particle is that the compositional nature of grain boundary precipitates is more complex near IPyC/SiC layer where Pd, Pd-Ag, Pd-U containing precipitates can be observed. However, the compositions of precipitate towards outer most region of SiC mainly contain Pd. Ag has been observed in the IPyC/SiC layer in one of the two locations. Comparison of the results to previously irradiated and analyzed, Variant 3, safety tested AGR-1 TRISO particles (AGR1-433-001 and AGR1 222-RS004) showed the grain boundary distributions have some noticeable differences. The differences in coincident site lattice grain boundary and misorientation angles are possibly inherent to the fabrication process. Neutron irradiation induced void distribution has been found to be nonuniform. A high concentration of smaller voids is found at stacking faults compared to those in the SiC matrix. Larger void sizes are observed in the SiC location that is near to the broken buffer layer. This void size variation with integrity of buffer layer can potentially affect the fission product retention. However, the average void size continuously decreases along the radius of SiC in both locations.
Given the unique characteristics of the PBR fuel cycle, both gamma and neutron measurements are expected to play important roles in performing and maintaining nuclear material control and accounting for spent pebbles to safeguard the fuel cycle. Given the lack of irradiated pebbles in the US, a variety of irradiated TRISO fuel samples with wide ranges of burnups and cooling times available at ORNL were used in this work. A large number of gamma and neutron measurements have been performed on these samples to collect data to test the various detectors and to benchmark the computer models to simulate the depletion and decay of the fuel and the measurements themselves. Two neutron detectors, including a custom-made detector and the Very High-Performance Neutron Multiplicity Counting, were used to measure the neutrons emitted by these TRISO samples. Three gamma spectrometry detectors, including an HPGe and the M400 CZT detector, were used to measure gamma-ray emissions from these samples. The M400 was recently adopted by the IAEA for fresh uranium measurements, but it was tested for spent fuel measurements prior to this project. Detailed MCNP models were developed to simulate these neutron and gamma measurements. Some GADRAS models were also developed to cross check the MCNP models for the gamma measurements. It was found challenging to perform neutron measurements in the hot cell due to the high background counts. Close agreements were observed between the simulated and measured neutron count rates in both detectors’ measurements of californium calibration sources. Both the HPGe and M400 detectors were able to measure the 604 and 662 keV peaks from these samples, which are the two most important peaks used to infer fuel burnup. Although the M400 detector did not have nearly good energy resolution and did not detect some of the minor peaks as the HPGe detector, it was found to be capable of handling significantly higher dose rates than HPGe. Given the complexities in the TRISO samples (e.g., different samples sizes) and uncertainties in the alignments between the detector and the TRISO fuel inside the containers, large scatters were found between the peak area rates and the samples’ burnups. However, the 604/662 peak ratios were found to trend well with the samples’ burnups among most samples in both measured and simulated results.
INL is leading the development and testing of accident tolerant fuels: fuels that resist melting down and that contain radioactive byproducts, preventing their release into their environment. One such fuel, called TRi-structural ISOtropic particle fuel (TRISO) See Fig 1. Understanding how heat propagates through a fuel is essential to fuel development and qualification. When irradiated in a reactor the properties that affect heat transport change. Our objective is to quantify the change in thermal properties of TRISO after irradiation.
Silicon carbide (SiC) passive thermometry has emerged as a promising post-irradiation examination (PIE) technique for estimating irradiation temperature near the end of irradiation. While dilatometry techniques have been traditionally used to analyze prismatic samples after irradiation, Raman spectroscopy has recently been shown to provide comparable results by analyzing Raman-active phonon modes. In this work, Raman spectroscopy has been applied to the SiC layer of cross-sectioned irradiation tristructural isotropic (TRISO) particles from the AGR-5/6/7 experiment to evaluate the feasibility of particle-scale passive thermometry. Two-dimensional Raman mapping was used to measure the position of the SiC longitudinal optical (LO) phonon, which was then converted to an apparent irradiation temperature using a previously established empirical correlation. Particles from AGR-5/6/7 Compacts 2-2-1 and 5-1-3 were selected as their calculated time-averaged, volume-averaged (TAVA) temperatures (828°C and 706°C, respectively) fall within the range of the sensitivity of the experimental approach. The use of SiC thermometry was anticipated to confirm or highlight potential deviations from calculated end-of-life TAVA temperature across compacts. Four particles from Compact 2-2-1 and two particles from Compact 5-1-3 were selected based on 110mAg inventory (either some measurable activity or below the minimum detection limit) which is commonly used as an indicator of in-pile temperature variation of particles within the same compact. Across every particle selected it was determined that the average LO peak position was located around 968 cm-1 to 969 cm-1. Using the previously determined empirical correlation, this corresponds to an irradiation temperature around 950°C to 966°C, which does not align with the reported TAVA temperature values. This discrepancy in apparent irradiation temperatures likely reflects a combination of uncertainties in the calculated particle temperatures and differences in irradiation history between the present specimens and those used to establish the empirical Raman calibration such as neutron flux (damage rate) and SiC microstructure (as fabricated and irradiated).
In this work, the morphology in the interface region between the inner pyrolytic carbon layer (IPyC) and silicon carbide (SiC) layers in tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) particle fuel from the AGR-2 irradiation experiment were studied using focused ion beam-scanning electron microscopy tomography. This work quantitatively described the interface and corresponding relevant metrics to understand how the microstructural features at the IPyC/SiC interface may influence actinide and fission product interactions with the SiC layer. Particles were selected with varied 110m Ag retention rates, and their volumes were reconstructed and analyzed for distributions of pores, fission product/actinide features, SiC, and IPyC. It was found that porosity accommodates fission products in the interface and SiC layers. The largest fission product/actinide precipitates were found in the interface region. This was also where the largest number fraction of fission products/actinides was found, consistent with SEM showing fission product/actinide pileup along selected areas of the interface region.
Tristructural-isotropic (TRISO)-coated fuel particles are used in high-temperature gas-cooled nuclear reactors. Although the polycrystalline 3C-SiC layer acts as the main barrier to fission product release, post-irradiation examinations have shown that certain metallic fission products are found outside of the TRISO coated particle, with no observable micro-cracks or other mechanical failure feature. In this study, an atomic resolution transmission electron microscopy investigation of a SiC layer of a neutron irradiated (19.38% fissions per initial metal atom average burnup; 1072°C time-averaged temperature) TRISO-coated particle from the first advanced gas reactor experiment at Idaho National Laboratory containing mainly Pd and U was conducted. The fission product Pd was found to be present at dislocation cores associated with twins, stacking faults, and their intersections. The Pd present at the dislocation cores were bonded to Si, suggesting that the diffusion of Pd along the SiC dislocation cores involves the formation of Pd-Si bonds. Evidence of single atom grain boundary migration was also found. Fission product agglomerations at grain boundaries most likely consist of a random solid solution containing Si-FP, Si-C, and C-C type bonding arrangements. No difference in the Si- or C-bonding environment is found for the unoccupied grain boundary adjacent to a fission product agglomeration compared to the bulk SiC.
The SCALE code system was used to model, deplete, and compare several different TRISO-fueled reactor designs: a helium-cooled prismatic reactor, a helium-cooled pebble-bed reactor (PBR), and a Fluoride-Lithium-Beryllium (FLIBE) molten-salt-cooled PBR. The purpose of this comparison was to understand how differences in the reactor designs affect the radioactivity of the fuel after discharge and whether those differences are significant. First, the various reactor designs were build and depleted in the TRITON module for each design and fuel enrichment. Then, the TRITON outputs were used to create burn-up dependent reactor libraries. These libraries were then used by ORIGEN to determine the activities of discharged fuel for each reactor, which were compared to generic Westinghouse 17x17 fuel. Overall, the results showed that short term decays are dominated by reactors with higher operating powers, and the reactor type, initial fuel enrichment, and maximum burn-up are of only secondary importance. Although this analysis only focuses on activities in becquerels, these dependencies are consistent with the expected behavior of decay heat. However, analysis of long- term time periods post-irradiation shows that the reactor type and maximum burn-up have strong impacts on the activities; initial fuel enrichment has a secondary impact while operating power is inconsequential. These results would be useful for analyses, such as dose assessment and modeling in post- release scenarios; normal fuel handling operations; and spent fuel transport, storage and disposal. Of particular interest, the results in this report show that analyses that focus on spent nuclear fuel of advanced reactors need to consider each parameter carefully. Unsurprisingly, if the correct operating power is not used in short term analyses, the results will not be correct. Perhaps unexpectedly, however, if the correct reactor type is not used, then the long term results will also be incorrect, especially for areas such as permanent disposal. Even though this report focuses on the total activity of nuclear fuel, it provides initial results on the effects of various input parameters and also provides a framework to extend the work into other analyses of spent fuel from advanced reactors, especially those employing TRISO fuel.
A furnace system was developed to thermally expose individual tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) coated particles to expand upon established postirradiation examination (PIE) safety testing that is used to explore particle failures and fission product release from compacts. Two systems were installed in the Irradiated Fuels Examination Facility (IFEL) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). The targeted design was intended to be simple and flexible to allow a range in conditions to be explored. Initial inert atmosphere testing indicated the presence of particle failures, so modifications to the testing approach were implemented to improve the furnace operation. Ultimately, burnback particles were analyzed to provide a direct measurement of fission product release, thus avoiding the complications from integral release that were observed during whole compact testing. Particles were exposed to temperatures ranging 1,150–1,300°C for up to 1,500 h and 1,600°C up to 500 h. No indication of uniform release of fission products such as 106 Ru, 125 Sb, or 154 Eu was observed, however, indication of particle dependent 154 Eu release was suggested for select particles. Exploration of 110m Ag release was limited to 1,150°C and 1,300°C up to 500 h. The analysis indicated that there was nonuniform release of 110m Ag and supports a possible bimodal temperature dependence on silver release.
Not Available
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel is being proposed for use in several high-temperature advanced reactor concepts because of its structural integrity under high operating temperatures and burnup. One of these advanced reactor concepts is the Kairos Power fluoride salt-cooled high-temperature reactor (KP- FHR) under development by Kairos Power, LLC. Previous TRISO irradiation experiments were focused on qualification for high-temperature gas reactors (HTGRs), which have higher operating temperatures but lower particle powers than the KP-FHR design. To study the performance of TRISO fuel designed for HTGRs under prototypical FHR conditions, a set of experiments was designed using the MiniFuel irradiation vehicle at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s (ORNL) High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). The experiments will irradiate 30 TRISO-containing carbon matrix compacts at inner small vertical experiment facilities in HFIR. Each compact will contain 20 TRISO particles (600 particles total) developed for HTGRs, consisting of either 14% enriched uranium dioxide uranium carbide, naturally enriched uranium dioxide, uranium carbide, or 9.6% enriched uranium dioxide fuel kernels with time- and volume-averaged silicon carbide layer temperatures between 500 and 900°C. This report summarizes the vehicle designs that have been developed, as well as the neutronic and thermal analyses completed for these irradiation experiments. These analyses show that MiniFuel compact irradiation is a versatile experiment that can be used to study a range of TRISO particle powers and fuel types while providing reasonable separation of burnup and temperature effects.
As part of efforts to strengthen INL?s post irradiation analysis capabilities with non-Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuels, two developmental activities were conducted. The first activity was to determine how best to analyze uranium nitride TRISO fuel kernels using electron probe microanalysis, while the second activity focused on developing a method to deconsolidate TRISO fuel particles that have been encased in a silicon carbide matrix. Because these two activities were unrelated, they have been presented separately in this report. Initial EPMA analyses showed nitrogen contents that far exceeded the concentration expected for UN--a line compound. Further examination showed that current literature values for the mass absorption coefficient (MAC) for the N ka X-ray absorbed by U ranged from approximately 1600 to 9500, with most values tending toward 9500. Measuring UN with five different progressively increasing accelerating voltages followed by using the modeling program xMAC suggests the actual MAC is approximately 2115. Additional MAC modifications were required to produce reasonable analytical results. Because of the inaccuracies of necessary MAC coefficients, UN analysis via scanning electron microscopy (SEM) is likely to produce inaccurate results. This is because SEM software does not typically allow the user to alter MACs. Tests have been performed to examine the feasibility of an electrochemical technique to liberate irradiated TRISO fuel from a SiC matrix without damaging the outer pyrolytic carbon layer of the fuel particle. The method is performed by electrochemically exposing the SiC to magnesium metal forming Mg2Si and C. Following exposure, the small SiC samples showed slight mass increases with no evidence of conversion to Mg2Si and C nor obvious degradation of the SiC samples.
Post-irradiation examination (PIE) of MiniFuel compacts was conducted at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) under the Nuclear Science User Facilities project in collaboration with Kairos Power (KP) to evaluate the performance of tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) particles under high particle power and fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactor (FHR)-relevant conditions. MiniFuel compacts containing low-enriched uranium oxide-uranium carbide (LEUCO), low-enriched uranium dioxide (LEUO2), and natural UCO (NUCO) kernels were irradiated for four cycles at ORNL’s High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at target temperatures between 500°C and 900°C. Post irradiation, the experiment was disassembled at ORNL to recover the MiniFuel subcapsules, which were subsequently punctured to measure fission gas release. Subcapsule disassembly allowed the recovery of components of interest, such as silicon carbide (SiC) thermometry, fuel specimens, fission product sinks, and SiC spacers. The experimental irradiation temperature was confirmed by analyzing the SiC thermometry via dilatometry. PIE on the fuel specimens included gamma spectrometry and deconsolidation leach burn leach, which were complemented by imaging techniques such as x-ray computed tomography, optical microscopy, and electron microscopy. The PIE results provide insight into TRISO particle integrity, fission product retention, coating performance, and kernel migration, informing fuel qualification for application in KP’s FHR concept.
Post-irradiation examination (PIE) of MiniFuel compacts was conducted at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) under the Nuclear Science User Facilities project in collaboration with Kairos Power (KP) to evaluate the performance of tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) particles under high particle power and fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactor (FHR)-relevant conditions. MiniFuel compacts containing low-enriched uranium oxide-uranium carbide (LEUCO), low-enriched uranium dioxide (LEUO 2 ), and natural UCO (NUCO) kernels were irradiated for four cycles at ORNL’s High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at target temperatures between 500°C and 900°C. Post irradiation, the experiment was disassembled at ORNL to recover the MiniFuel subcapsules, which were subsequently punctured to measure fission gas release. Subcapsule disassembly allowed the recovery of components of interest, such as silicon carbide (SiC) thermometry, fuel specimens, fission product sinks, and SiC spacers. The experimental irradiation temperature was confirmed by analyzing the SiC thermometry via dilatometry. PIE on the fuel specimens included gamma spectrometry and deconsolidation leach burn leach, which were complemented by imaging techniques such as x-ray computed tomography, optical microscopy, and electron microscopy. The PIE results provide insight into TRISO particle integrity, fission product retention, coating performance, and kernel migration, informing fuel qualification for application in KP’s FHR concept.
An irradiation experiment using tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel particles and the miniature fuel (MiniFuel) irradiation vehicle was performed in Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to support development of the Kairos Power fluoride salt–cooled, high-temperature reactor (KP-FHR). Here, this paper describes modeling predictions of temperatures and fuel burnup for the as-built experiment. An uncertainty quantification (UQ) analysis was performed to determine the effect of TRISO particle volume and position on the temperature predictions at various fuel heat generation rates (HGRs). This UQ study utilized fuel kernel position and volume measurements previously collected using X-ray computed tomography (XCT) techniques and Monte Carlo sampling methods to generate fuel compact cases that were then analyzed using a finite element thermal model. The UQ analysis indicated that uncertainty in calculated temperatures caused by varying TRISO particle arrangement is relatively small, even at high fuel HGR. Final predictions of particle temperatures throughout the irradiation are shown to be relevant to KP-FHR normal and off-normal operating conditions and to previous TRISO irradiation experiments. The combination of XCT with UQ analyses will inform post-irradiation examination (PIE) of the irradiated fuel compacts, and these analyses can be used to develop fuel performance models for coated particle fuel forms. Both PIE of separate-effects irradiation data and enhanced fuel performance modeling support accelerated qualification of TRISO fuels for a broad range of advanced reactor applications. The novel approach demonstrated here of measuring TRISO particle configurations with XCT methods and generating representative fuel compacts for finite element modeling and UQ analysis could be leveraged by the broader particle fuel community in the development of other TRISO fuel experiments in which these variables may have a significant impact on key outcomes.