Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Olivas, Eric Richard

Publications and source records attributed to Olivas, Eric Richard.

At least 19 records

Development of an accelerator-based neutron source to prototype Mo-99 production, part I: A liquid LBE windowless target

In this article, Molybdenum-99 (Mo-99)’s decay product, technetium-99 (Tc-99 m), is one of the most critical isotopes for medical diagnostics. To provide U.S. domestic supply of Mo-99 without using high-enriched uranium (HEU), a subcritical uranium target assembly (UTA) is irradiated by an accelerator-based neutron source to create Mo-99 through fission. This study discusses the development of the accelerator-based neutron source. The high-energy electrons from the accelerator irradiate a liquid lead-bismuth eutectic (LBE) target to produce neutrons. Part I of this work focuses on numerical and experimental analysis towards the development of a liquid LBE windowless target. Unlike the existing windowless targets in literature, the current design creates a vertical free surface for a beam to irradiate. First, a hydrodynamic analysis of the LBE windowless target is performed. Simplified analytical calculations are assisted by 2D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations to design the target, with the focus on eliminating recirculation zones and avoiding cavitation. With the optimized geometry, the experimental study is performed to investigate the flow hydrodynamics using liquid LBE. The experiments (1) compare pressure drop in the system to correlation predictions; (2) visualize the free surface liquid LBE flow from the beam view; (3) validate the LBE flow profile using temperature sensitive paint from the side view; and (4) validate the liquid LBE film thickness using gamma densitometer measurements. Second, the power handling capability of the designed windowless target is investigated. The divider plate in the current design is susceptible to overheating due to the thin LBE film in front. As LBE erosion and corrosion is likely to occur at an LBE velocity of 2.0 m/s and temperature above 500 °C, a power limit of 10 kW of beam power was established to prevent this corrosion from occurring, which is calculated by a Nusselt number correlation. The divider plate surface temperature at 10 kW agrees well with the 3D CFD simulation results. Part I demonstrates the fundamental physics in liquid LBE windowless target design and associated testing. A companion paper, Part II will demonstrate how to couple this windowless target into the Mo-99 production system, including an accelerator system operating under an ultra-high vacuum and the UTA cooled by water at room temperature.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Development of an accelerator-based neutron source to prototype Mo-99 production, Part II: A liquid LBE loop under a high vacuum

To provide US domestic supply of Mo-99 without using high-enriched uranium (HEU), a subcritical uranium target assembly (UTA) is irradiated by an accelerator-based neutron source to create Mo-99 through fission. Part I of this work discusses the design of a liquid lead–bismuth eutectic (LBE) windowless target for an accelerator-based neutron source development. Part II discusses how to couple this windowless target to an accelerator operating at an ultra-high vacuum and the subcritical UTA cooled by water at room temperature. Due to the windowless design of the target, the liquid LBE flow shares an ultra-high vacuum (<1.3 × 10 -7 Pa or 10 -9 Torr) space with the accelerator. As a result of this shared vacuum space, the LBE system must operate at a high vacuum (10 -3 ~10 -6 Pa or 10 -5 ~10 -8 Torr). A magnetic rotary motion feedthrough unit utilizes magnetic fluid to allow rotation of the pump while maintaining a high vacuum environment. Prior to testing the LBE system under vacuum, a pump curve measurement is performed to estimate flowrate in the system. This measurement also generates data on orifice loss coefficients, which are compared to correlations in literature. The second experiment investigates vacuum level in the LBE system during operation. High vacuum is maintained (10 -3 ~10 -5 Pa or 10 -5 ~10 -7 Torr) during system operation, and a residual gas analyzer (RGA) scan shows that partial pressures of residual gases in the LBE system lower over the duration of LBE system operations. The third experiment investigates the gravity driven liquid LBE flowing out of the target chamber in the return line, which is partially full. If the liquid LBE is not drained quickly enough, flooding in the target chamber could occur. The coefficient n in the Manning equation is found to be around 0.008 s/m 1/3 . The last experiment performed is a demonstration that a vacuum jacket could provide sufficient thermal insulation to allow coupling between 300 °C LBE loop and a water tank at room temperature. In conclusion, the results from these experiments have influenced the development of the neutron source for the future commercial scale Mo-99 production system.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Niowave Neutron Source Converter: Lead-Bismuth-Eutectic (LBE) Windowless Target Design and Evaluation

Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) is working with Niowave on the design and evaluation of their lead-bismuth-eutectic (LBE) windowless target (i.e., neutron source converter). Niowave plans to use 200 kW electron beam at 40 MeV beam energy to produce neutrons by photonuclear reaction with LBE. Then, the neutrons undergo fission at the surrounding uranium target assembly (UTA) to produce Molybdenum 99 (Mo-99) as a fission product, which eventually decays to Technetium-99 (Tc-99m). Tc-99m is one of important radioisotopes that is used for medical diagnostics. LANL conducted 3D multiphysics analysis for the Niowave neutron converter design and provided design assessment in thermohydraulic aspects. LANL conducted radiation transport calculations using Monte-Carlo N-Particle (MCNP) code with unstructured meshing scheme. The 3D volumetric heating profiles in the LBE and Stainless-Steel (SS) housing were imported into multiphase computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to obtain 3D temperature profiles of LBE and SS through conjugate heat transfer (CHT) analysis. The key findings are: LBE film thickness at the center of the beam is approximately 1.6 cm with a maximum LBE velocity of approximately 1.8 m/s, which is below a 2 m/s limit to avoid erosion issues on supporting structures; Heat deposition in the LBE peaks at ~1 cm depth from the LBE free-surface because of the forward interactions of electron, photon, and neutron with LBE; LBE maximum temperature is ~360 °C, which is below LBE evaporation initiative temperature, ~450 °C; LBE-SS interface temperature is ~350 °C, which is below the safety thermal limit to prevent severe corrosion on SS. The results indicate that Niowave’s neutron converter design satisfies both hydraulic and thermal criteria for safe operation. By virtue of such computational analysis, Niowave can move toward establishing an experimental setup to experimentally test their LBE neutron converter. The following sections describe the detailed work done by LANL.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Conjugate Heat Transfer Analysis in Pressurized Helium Gas Cooling Channels

Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) is working with NorthStar Medical Radioisotopes (NMR) on their efforts to produce Mo-99 from the irradiation of Mo-100 targets. The NMR target consists of an Inconel window that allows the electron beam to penetrate and irradiate a stack of Mo-100 disks. The irradiation process generates large amounts of heat and is cooled using pressurized helium gas flowing at 400 g/s. LANL provides both numerical analysis support and experimental support. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and conjugate heat transfer (CHT) analysis are performed on the NMR target to analyze the helium flow and volumetric heating through the NMR system. In this iteration of numerical analysis, we update the Mo-100 disk thickness to 0.74 mm and the gap between the Inconel window and the first disk to 0.69 mm. Estimates of the heat flux from the electron beams from Monte Carlo N-Particle code (MCNP) analysis were combined with CFD to perform the CHT analysis. The pressure drop through the targets, force applied on the first disk, beam window and target disk temperatures are some of the quantities estimated using the simulations. The pressure drop through the target was estimated as 0.198 MPa, while the force due to venturi effects across the first disk was estimated to be 100 N. The results show maximum window temperatures over 600 °C and peak disk temperatures over 1600 °C. Past work has shown that beyond 650-700 °C, the Inconel window becomes susceptible to yield and rupture. The increased temperature in these results reduces the margin of error possible on beam spot size. The disk temperatures showed a sinusoidal distribution with the 6 th – 8 th disk from each window exhibiting highest disk temperatures. The peak temperature of the stainless steel housing was close to 316 °C and that of the laminations and spacers was approximately 582 °C.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Numerical Analysis and Flow Induced Vibration Studies in Pressurized Helium Gas Cooling Channels

Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) is working with NorthStar Medical Radioisotopes (NMR) on their efforts to produce Mo-99 from the irradiation of Mo-100 targets. The NMR target consists of an Inconel window that allows the electron beam to penetrate and irradiate a stack of Mo-100 discs. The irradiation process generates large amounts of heat and is cooled using pressurized helium gas flowing at 400 g/s. LANL provides both numerical analysis support and experimental support. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations for both 300 g/s and 400 g/s are performed on the NMR target to analyze the helium flow through the NMR system. The pressure drop, the mass flow rate through each of the disc and window channels and the force applied on the first disc are some of the quantities estimated using CFD. These results will be combined with Monte Carlo N-Particle (MCNP) estimates of heat flux into the system from the electron beam to perform conjugate heat transfer analysis (CHT). The experiments presented in this report focus on the effect of the flow induced vibrations from helium flowing through the coolant gaps between the discs. There is concern that the flow induced vibrations may lead to excessive mass loss of the enriched Mo-100 discs, and the goal would be to mitigate the mass loss. This work presents benchtop tests of flow through a subset of the target stack which involves high speed imaging and displacement measurements used to estimate disc vibration, as well as mass loss.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Development of experimental and computational frameworks to predict subcooled flow boiling in the LANL Isotope Production Facility

Cooling is crucial to maintain the integrity of target systems in isotope production facilities. At Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL)’s Isotope Production Facility (IPF), multiple encapsulated targets are stacked and irradiated in tandem with a 100 MeV, ~250μA proton beam. To facilitate effective heat removal, these stacked targets are separated and cooled via a series of water channels. At these beam currents, this high-energy proton beam heats the target system, likely initiating subcooled flow boiling in the cooling channels. However, in-beam monitoring of the IPF target system is not possible due to the extreme radiation environment, and the necessarily significant shielding. To better understand high-power target performance, we developed ex-situ experimental and computational frameworks to predict the behavior of subcooled flow boiling at IPF. Subcooled flow boiling experiments on Inconel 625 samples under IPF conditions (2 bar pressure, 10 GPM flow rate (i.e., 2249 kg/m 2 /s), 85 K subcooling) revealed that IPF's average operating power is at the early stage of boiling with a heat transfer coefficient of 48,000 W/m 2 /s. The proposed modeling framework enables us to predict a complete boiling curve, i.e., single-phase heat transfer, onset of nucleate boiling, two-phase heat transfer, and critical heat flux (CHF), with specification of input boiling parameters up to intermediate heat flux levels. The estimated CHF under IPF conditions is 5.2 MW/m 2 . Experimental data under reduced conditions (2 bar pressure, 1.5 GPM flow rate (i.e., 337 kg/m 2 /s), 45 K subcooling) served as validation cases for the computational modeling. This computational model can be further extended to more complicated systems replicating the real IPF configuration, for instance, to study void distribution as a function of the incident proton beam profile and coolant velocity profile of multiple cooling channels. Finally, the proposed experimental and computational frameworks provide a means to better understand cooling systems in the isotope production facilities at different accelerators, where in-beam monitoring of the cooling process is not available.

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Niowave Design and Analysis of a 200 kW Converter

LANL is providing support to Niowave Inc. on the design and analysis of a 200 kW converter. The current design of the 200 kW (40 MeV, 5 mA electron beam) converter consists of LBE flowing from the top to the bottom. When compared to the Mk.5 20 kW converter, which flowed LBE from the bottom, flowing over a divider plate to create a waterfall, the 200 kW converter eliminates the divider plate, which would otherwise have melted with the higher beam power. Because the LBE flows from the top to the bottom, alternate methods to the divider plate need to be utilized to ensure a stable flow that minimizes splashing at the bottom of the LBE waterfall, while maintaining a uniform LBE thickness at the beam, and steady LBE flow at the desired flow rate.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Niowave Design and Analysis of a High Power Converter - FY 21

LANL provided support to Niowave Inc. on the design and analysis of the Mk. 4 and Mk. 5, 20 kW converter. The Mk. 4 converter design consisted of lead bismuth eutectic (LBE) flowing over a divider plate to create a waterfall. Niowave, with feedback from LANL, improved on the Mk.4 divider plate and “horn” region of the converter to create the Mk. 5 version of the converter.

42 ENGINEERING↗

NorthStar Helium Cooling System. Final Report on LANL Contribution

From the beginning of NNSA support to the NorthStar development of a production facility for the medical isotope Molybdenum-99 (Mo99), LANL has been responsible for the design and testing of a target and its cooling. The target is comprised of a stack of Mo100 disks separated by coolant flow gaps between the disks and between the first disk and a housing window, which separates the target and its coolant from the vacuum of the beam line. The target, and therefore its cooling requirements, evolved steadily over the years of system development

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Northstar Mo99 Window Tests

Tests were completed for window to “first disk” (actually a steel plate for these expariments) gaps of 20 mil as per design gap as well as 10 mil and 30 mil gaps to span the range of possible variations. With possible disk distortion in beam, another test with 0 gap was performed. Based on deflections measured during the pressure test, the 0 gap was most likely very near 3 mil.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Target Optimization Study: Tolerance Sensitivity

A Work Package was initiated to investigate the potential for target optimization. The current design is made up of 82 disks 0.5 mm thick spaced 0.25 mm apart for helium coolant flow. This disk thickness and gap width are a result of continual increases is beam power and hence volumetric heating rate. Thickening the disks would mean higher disk temperatures, but this would be weighed against the prospect of fewer, thicker disks and wider coolant gap spaces, and the relaxed tolerances that would result. Fabrication of the target holder would be easier and less expensive, and target assembly would also be easier.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Northstar Mo100 Target Beam Spot Size Sensitivity Study

Northstar Mo100 target for production of the medical isotope Mo99 is particularly sensitive to beam over focusing because of the intended high power density. At 38 MeV and 6.32 mA (240 kW beam power, nominally 160 kW th in the target), small deviation from the nominal 12 mm FWHM beam can significantly increase the target disk temperatures and more importantly the load bearing target window temperature. A rhodotron will be the source of the electron beam to be used in the isotope production. This machine operates in a pulsed beam mode, currently expected to be at 50 Hz, which results in a 100 C temperature oscillation above and below the steady state temperature that is the focus of this study. This must be considered in the determination of minimum beam spot size that can be accepted by the target without risk of failure. In addition to the nominal beam spot size of 12 mm, the analysis of 10, 11 and 14.5 mm beam spot sizes are analyzed. The primary conclusion is that an over focused beam to just 11 mm FWHM is the minimum beam spot allowable, based on window temperature and the Ultimate Tensile Stress (UTS) of the window material Inconel 718 as a function of temperature. In contrast an under focused beam of 14.5 mm FWHM has much reduced target and window temperatures, but there is a resulting 6% drop in isotope production, all other factor staying the same. These results are presented herein.

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Niowave Power Converter Modeling and Testing

Niowave has designed, built and is now using in-beam a low power (up to 10 kW) lead bismuth eutectic (LBE) converter. In this concept, an electron beam is passed through a falling layer of LBE, converting the electron to neutrons which then pass into a vessel which is functionally a subcritical reactor configuration. A detailed report has been written by Niowave, entitled “LBE Neutron Converter Manual.” The LANL contribution has been modeling, followed by a flow visualization model made in quartz. The LANL contribution is reported herein.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Novel design and diagnostics improvements for increased production capacity and improved reliability at the Los Alamos Isotope Production Facility

The Isotope Production Facility (IPF) at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) is used to produce an array of isotopes for medical, global security, and research applications with an intense beam of protons supplied by the linear accelerator at the Los Alamos Neutron Science Center (LANSCE). An Accelerator Improvement Project (AIP) was recently conducted at IPF to improve facility reliability and reduce programmatic risk while increasing general isotope production capacity and flexibility. This was accomplished through the installation of an improved beam window assembly, more robust beam diagnostics, an active and adjustable collimator, and a new beam rastering system. This paper will highlight the four exciting innovations and how they were designed, validated, and installed in parallel as well as the significant operational advantages they provide to IPF. Key experiments and the increased currents achieved in routine production runs demonstrating the enhanced capability from the AIP will be presented. As a result, the most notable capability enhancements include irradiations with beam currents ranging from 100 nA experimental runs up to 300 μA on routine production targets and utilization of a range of cylindrical target diameters.

100 MeV protons↗

Analysis of the Rhodotron Pulsed Beam Impact on the Northstar Mo100 Target Window

Northstar has elected to use rhodotrons rather than linear accelerators to deliver the electron beam to their targets. This decision has imposed a much lower frequency beam pulse on the target, resulting in short duration high power deposition. The impact on the target window is of particular importance.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗