Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Timothy M Smith

Publications and source records attributed to Timothy M Smith.

Influences of Introduced Yttrium Oxide Particles on Superalloy 718

Additive manufacturing has proven useful for introducing oxide particles into superalloys, to provide oxide dispersion strengthening (ODS) at high temperatures. This study screened how such an approach can influence microstructure and failure modes for superalloy 718. The objective of this study was to compare tensile and creep failure modes for additively manufactured superalloy 718 having introduced oxide particles. Fine yttrium-oxide (yttria) particles were introduced into 718 powder using two different powder mixing methods. Additive manufacturing by laser powder bed fusion was then used to prepare specimen blanks for each case, oriented parallel and transverse to the building direction. These were subsequently given consistent stress relief, hot isostatic pressurization, and final heat treatments, then subjected to tensile and creep tests at varied temperatures. Additively manufactured 718 without ODS (“no-ODS”) had nearly equiaxed grains at 50 μm in width. Roll-mixed ODS material had a bimodal grain size distribution, with fine grains at 9 μm and coarse grains at 66 μm in average width. The fine grains were elongated about 5x in the building direction. Acoustic-mixed ODS materials had grains at 10 μm in width that were elongated about 10x in the build direction. Compared to no-ODS, roll-mixed and acoustic mixed ODS materials did not show improved tensile strengths at room temperature, 760 °C, and 1093 °C. The tensile failure strains parallel to the building direction of roll-mixed ODS material were lowest in these tests. Flattened clumps of yttria had formed transverse to the building direction in roll-mixed material, which were easily cracked. Creep rupture response at 760 °C in the building direction was highest for acoustic-mixed material test. Creep tests at 1093 °C showed varied results, with low rupture lives associated with enhanced cavitation at grain boundaries and surface oxidation. Transverse to the building direction, all three materials had low failure strains in tests at 760 °C. The elongated grain boundaries failed readily in all transverse specimens tested at 760 °C and 1093 °C.

oxide dispersion strengthening↗

Evaluation of Superalloy 718 Additively Manufactured Lattice Blocks

Lattice block structures made up of high temperature superalloys could offer advantages in density, efficiency, and tailored properties. Three candidate lattice designs were screened through additive manufacturing of superalloy 718. Laser powder bed fusion was applied with 718 powder to produce lattice blocks for three-dimensional octahedral unit cell designs of three heights. As-designed versus additively manufactured 718 lattices were compared, including structural dimensions, densities, defects, grain structures, crystallographic texture, and surface residual stresses. Manufactured lattice I diverged the most from its design, with both corner and center nodes merged into continuous columns. Manufactured lattice III came closest to its design, though the actual nodes and struts were still larger in cross section than in the design. Only modest grain coarsening and negligible chemical segregation were observed for all three designs, suggesting uniform thermo-physical and mechanical properties are possible. Significant tensile residual stresses were present at the surface of the manufactured blocks, with highest stresses in the building direction. Current findings indicate this concept could produce useful superalloy structures for high-temperature-capable static components requiring tailored density, and thermo-physical/mechanical properties.

super alloys↗

Effects of Alloying Elements on Twinning in Ni-Based Superalloys

Micro-twinning is the major creep deformation mechanism in Ni-based superalloys at temperatures above 700 C. Recent experiments suggest that superlattice stacking faults in   phase may serve as the precursors to twin formation. Segregation of alloying elements to these precursors may have a significant effect on formation and extension of micro-twins. Using atomistic modeling we investigate and explain the effects of Cr and Nb alloying additions on these processes. Our results help to rationalize the experimentally observed puzzling effects of elemental composition of the alloy on creep resistance.

Ni-based superalloys↗

Extreme Temperature Additively Manufactured GRX-810 Alloy Development and Hot-fire Testing for Liquid Rocket Engines

Additive manufacturing (AM) has revolutionized component design for liquid rocket engines by offering rapid manufacturing capabilities. This has led to significant opportunities for development and flight programs in the propulsion industry, resulting in cost and schedule savings, as well as performance improvements through new designs and alloy development. A noteworthy example is the GRX-810 oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloy, which was specifically developed for extreme temperatures. This Ni-Co-Cr based alloy was created using integrated computational materials engineering (ICME) techniques to focus on a new class of materials with exceptional temperature and oxidation-resistant properties. The GRX-810 alloy utilizes AM processes to incorporate nano-scale yttria particles throughout its microstructure, resulting in remarkable enhancements. Compared to traditional Nickel-based superalloys, the GRX-810 alloy offers a two-fold increase in tensile strength, 1,000-fold better creep properties, and two-fold improvement in oxidation resistance. NASA successfully demonstrated the development and manufacturing of components using the GRX-810 alloy through laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) and laser powder directed energy deposition (LP-DED) processes. Extensive efforts were made to model, evaluate metallurgical properties, develop heat treatment processes, characterize the microstructure, and determine mechanical properties. The GRX-810 alloy was specifically designed for aerospace applications, including liquid rocket engine injectors, preburners, turbines, and hot-section components, capable of withstanding temperatures up to 1,100 °C. The objective of this alloy development is to bridge the temperature gap between traditional Nickel-based superalloys and refractory alloys. This paper provides a comprehensive comparison of the GRX-810 alloy with other aerospace alloys, discussing its microstructure, mechanical properties, processing advancements, component development, and hot-fire testing results. The ultimate goal of this development was to elevate the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of the GRX-810 alloy, enabling its integration into NASA and commercial aerospace applications.

GRX-810↗

Superior Tensile Creep Behavior of A Novel Oxide Dispersion Strengthened Crconi Multi-Principal Element Alloy

The creep behavior of an additively manufactured (AM) yttrium oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) CrCoNi multi-principal element alloy (MPEA) is investigated in this study. Tests were conducted over a constant tensile stress range of 40–200 MPa and a temperature range of 973–1173 K. A stress exponent of 6.5 ± 0.1 and activation energies in the range of 335–367 kJ/mol were measured. Compared to its non-ODS counterpart and its parent alloy (CrMnFeCoNi), AM ODS CrCoNi has superior creep resistance at all tested stresses and temperatures. The mechanism contributing to the excellent creep resistance of AM ODS CrCoNi is attributed to the interaction of mixed character dislocations with oxide particles. The creep ductility of AM ODS CrCoNi is higher than its nonODS counterpart due to a large percentage of low angle grain boundaries associated with its columnar grain structure. It was also found that creep ductility is significantly greater at the highest applied stress of 200 MPa compared to lower stresses. The steady state dislocation structure of AM ODS CrCoNi consists of long arrays of dislocations, which is different from that observed in non-ODS CrCoNi which consists of individual curved dislocations.

Seyed Gianmarco Sahragard-Monfared↗

The Effect of Composition on Microstructure and Properties for Additively Manufactured Superalloy 718

Additive manufacturing (AM) represents an exciting new approach towards producing metallic aerospace components. The ability to make complex geometries that were impossible to create using conventional manufacturing methods has sparked interest from the aerospace community, including NASA. The use of AM components for crucial and human rated space missions necessitates a full characterization of the differences between AM and more conventional wrought and cast processes. For this study, sixteen different commercially available superalloy 718 powder feedstocks were obtained, built using laser powder bed fusion(L-PBF), and microstructurally and mechanically analyzed. These measurements revealed a wide range of build qualities and microstructures despite all powder lots falling within the 718chemical specification and being processed using the same prescribed build and heat treatment parameters. Statistical analysis found a strong correlation of the amount of carbon in the powder with the final grain size and strength of the heat-treated 718 part. Ultimately, this study highlights the need of a refined superalloy 718 chemical specification for powder lots to be used in AM.

Timothy M Smith↗

Guided Design of Alloys, Strengthened via Precipitation

Using theoretical and computational guidance, we are designing stronger middle and high-entropy alloys and superalloys for the airspace applications. We focus on improving mechanical properties of materials at cryogenic and elevated temperatures. Here we discuss basic science and fundamental theory that are being used for guided design of next-generation alloys. As examples, we consider the medium-entropy NiCoCr alloy and precipitated superalloys with a local phase transformation strengthening. This research is funded by NASA’s Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate (ARMD) via Transformational Tools and Technologies (TTT) Project.

Alloys↗

Guided Design of Alloys

Using multiscale materials modeling, we are designing stronger alloys for the airspace applications. We focus on improving mechanical properties of materials at operating temperature. We employ basic science and fundamental theory for guided design of the next-generation alloys. Among the examples, we consider precipitated superalloys with a local phase transformation strengthening. We acknowledge funding by NASA’s Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate (ARMD) via Transformational Tools and Technologies (TTT) Project.

multiscale↗

High-precision predictions of properties of chemically disordered crystals

Multiple scattering theory (MST) combined with density functional theory (DFT) allows to predict properties of chemically disordered materials from the first principles. However, such predictions often suffer from the systematic errors, which depend on crystal geometry. Each computed property of a particular crystal structure typically has a relatively small random error and a larger systematic error. Cancellation of systematic errors allows more accurate predictions. We propose a computational methodology based on the subtraction of the systematic errors in MST. To exemplify it, we apply it to the precipitated alloys. Considering precipitation strengthening in Ni superalloys, we compute the relative enthalpies of the competing Ni3(Al,Ti)1 crystal structures with a chemical disorder on the Al+Ti sublattice. Such predicted composition-structure-property dependencies are useful for the guided design of the next-generation alloys with improved strength. Our predictions are validated by comparison with the results of other DFT methods (having a higher computational cost) and with experiment. We acknowledge funding of the guided design of stronger superalloys for airspace by NASA Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate (ARMD) via Transformational Tools and Technologies (TTT) Project.

Computational↗

Effect of Alloying Additions on Twinning in Ni-based Superalloys

Micro-twinning is the dominant creep deformation mechanism in Ni-based superalloys at temperatures above 700 °C. We use atomistic simulations to study two mechanisms of twin nucleation and growth that are characterized by qualitatively different rate limiting processes. In case of the mechanism proposed by Kolbe, the rate limiting process is diffusion-mediated atomic reshuffling. In case of the other mechanism, we proposed recently, the rate limiting process is nucleation of Shockley partial dislocation. We demonstrate the effects of alloying additions on functionality of these mechanisms.

Valery V Borovikov↗

Energy landscape in Ni-Co-Cr and related alloys

Among multi-principal element alloys, the NiCoCr middle-entropy alloy has an outstanding combination of strength and ductility at both low and elevated temperatures. Equiatomic NiCoCr is a single-phase alloy with the face centered cubic (fcc) crystal structure. A low stacking fault energy in the fcc matrix is a cause of a relatively low creep in this alloy. The hexagonal close-packed (hcp) structure differs from the fcc by a stacking of atomic layers. The energy difference between the hcp and fcc structures is known to correlate with the stacking fault energy in the fcc phase. We compute formation and relative structural energies versus composition in the Ni-Co-Cr ternary and related quaternary systems, discuss possibilities of compositional adjustments, and compare theoretical predictions with experiment. We acknowledge funding by NASA’s Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate (ARMD) via Transformational Tools and Technologies (TTT) Project.

NiCoCr↗

Electrical Discharge Machining of Additively Manufactured Superalloys Containing Oxide Dispersions

Superalloys can be strengthened by oxide dispersions to potentially improve their mechanical properties at high temperatures. Additive manufacturing has opened new paths for introducing oxide particles into superalloys with increased processing flexibility, to potentially provide oxide dispersion strengthening. Numerically controlled electrical discharge machining (EDM) has often been used as a machining process for initial sectioning, detailed roughing, and even finishing operations of conventional superalloys. The objective of this study was to examine how additively manufactured superalloys containing oxide dispersions respond when sectioned using EDM. Consistent sections of several superalloys, two containing an oxide dispersion, were sliced using a typical EDM machine with standard brass wire and a typical roughing condition set. Roughness, microstructure, and residual stress at the EDM surfaces were compared for the varied superalloys.

superalloys↗

Evaluations of Additively Manufactured Superalloy Lattice Blocks

Cast lattice block structures made up of high-temperature superalloys were previously shown to offer advantages in density, efficiency, and tailored properties. However, inconsistencies in casting die-fill, composition, and microstructure were identified as persistent issues with the casting process path. Three candidate lattice designs were screened through additive manufacturing of a superalloy. Laser powder bed fusion was applied with superalloy powder to produce lattice blocks for three-dimensional octahedral unit-cell designs of three heights. Properties of the structural designs versus additively manufactured lattices were compared, including structural dimensions, densities, defects, grain structures, crystallographic texture, and surface residual stresses. Findings indicate this concept could produce useful superalloy structures for high-temperature-capable static components requiring tailored density, and thermophysical and mechanical properties.

superalloy↗